DBQ: Roosevelt’s New Plan
Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) began a revolution in politics during his presidency from 1933-1945 with the new deal. The United States was going through a great depression when he gained the presidency and, unlike the president before him, FDR chose to take an active role in helping Americans get back on their feet. He made an unprecedented movement, The New Deal. To understand this better, a broader historical context should be stated. The United States had just gotten out of WWI. At first, businesses boomed. The average household income was higher than ever before. People were living lavish lives of partying and organized crime rose spectacularly in reaction to prohibition. Farmers were farming their land dry to keep up with the demand from the now rich United States and the many European countries thrust into poverty from war debt. Germany suffered most of all. The United States lent out loans to Germany to make sure that they could pay their debt to the European countries. All this luck began to fail in the 1920s. The farmland began to collapse, land too dry and lift from overwork. America lost their main source of produce and farmers, the group dedicated the backbone of our nation several times throughout history, lost their income. The credit that Americans had mindlessly taken out they were incapable of paying back. Banks lost people’s money and people lost trust in banks. All around the nation, Americans started pulling their money out of their repositories, taking stocks out of the market, and guarding what they had near. Because of this sudden influx,
Ultimately, FDR’s New Deal policy managed to lift America into high standard once again. Still, it was a heavily flawed system. Either way, the United States government was pulled into a new era of actively assisting its citizens in need.
The Great Depression was hard time for every American and Franklin D. Roosevelt did everything in his power to assure that Americans would find themselves in prosper once again.
His New Deal pulled together a multitude of organizations that were deemed the Alphabet Soup Agencies (ASA).
The unemployment rates farmers plummeted with FDR’s efforts (Doc 10), but farmers a but a margin of the American people.
FDR put efforts into other places as well but much of it went unnoticed or unappreciated.
He began a monthly check system to senior citizens that seemed overly generous to Americans (Doc 5).
Overspending was a huge worry for the already-in-debt American people and FDR seemed to be pulling money out of nowhere to put in everyone’s pot.
Helping the senile to stand on their feet didn’t help bring the nation running again but it still supported American people in need.
Six billion dollars were added to the national debt and some of the ASAs were retarding United States commerce.
As an unintended consequence of paying the people in need, people worried that United States citizens would become too reliant of federal assist (Doc 2).
They believed it would drive Americans lazy to know that there was always a cushion to fall back on.
This point is valid and still a well debated issue in today’s America.
Still, the letter given to the United States Senator was likely written by a white male with a steady source of income.
The dialect and content suggest that he has a position of power in business.
He has an emotional investment not often shared with lower grunt employees.
Because of this potential bias his argument is a tad unsteady.
The New Deal worked and few people used the added help to laze around.
It wasn’t enough to provide for a lavish lifestyle, just enough to make sure that people didn’t give up altogether.
Two ASAs (NRA and AAA) were so poorly produced that when taken to the Supreme Court, they were ruled unconstitutional and abolished.
(Doc 6) The New Deal also failed to integrate assistance for women and people of color.
Women were abandoned and fired left and right during the Great Depression, probably more poor than the white man.
Still, they were hardly seen on the streets (Doc 1).
What horrible fate could have befallen on these women in such mass that they seemed to just disappear?
The new jobs FDR made for Americans hardly held place for women and the reduced price housing was allowed to deny them and people of color stay (Doc 9).
Some argued that the now shared poverty between black Americans and white would instill a sense of comrade rice between the groups, but it only managed to push people of color into a further corner with the continued deny of jobs and housing because of the color of their skin.
Racism and sexism were allowed to take a new leap with the help of FDR’s system of facilitation.
Ultimately, America made it out of the depression.
Still, FDR’s way of doing so left more than a few harmed marks.
Regardless of how effective FDR’s tactics may have been, the president managed to change the way the United States Government functioned in a way that’s still in effect today. The United States government was built in the 1700s as a nation for the people and by the people. Still, people lived in immense poverty and had shallow security in wealth all across the nation while the federal politicians they’d voted in good idly by. To help the people that put law makers in place was the next natural step of a democracy. A way to move forward, even if it wasn’t especially revolutionary (Doc 3). While cartoons may make fun of this self-promoted fact, it’s true that because of it the transition was much more smooth and the intended effects of the New Deal were able to stick around. The New Deal forced America into a new world, with The New Republic (A popular political magazine founded in the early 1900s)’s full support (Doc 8). It was a liberal magazine that supported progress. Progress in our nation required changes to the way our government worked. The New Deal supported that progress.
Logging in, please wait... 
0 General Document comments
0 Sentence and Paragraph comments
0 Image and Video comments
New Conversation
The above paragraph is too small and the bottom one too big. plus it will allow your thesis to be able to be found easier.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
Acknowledge the debt argument and then refute it since you are arguing for the New Deal policy.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
Two ASAs (NRA and SECAAA) were so poorly produced that when taken to the Supreme Court, they were ruled unconstitutional and abolished.
Reason: The SEC was not the second program labeled unconstitutional, it was the AAA
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
General Document Comments 0