NowComment
Document: Invite Print Info
2-Pane Combined
Comments:
Full Summaries Sorted

Four Perspectives on Meaning in Literature

From Kyoko Sato, “On Common Ground.” Presidential Address, NCTE Annual Convention, Pittsburgh, PA, 2005

To share a common language is to stand on common ground. Teachers of English Language Arts speak the same language because we like to explore the multiple meanings of texts. We relish hearing the different perspectives from others who read the same text, and we delight in the different interpretations that emerge in our own readings when we revisit them at different stages in our lives.

While most people, especially our students, want to know the up-front meaning of a drama, a novel, or an editorial, we Englishy types savor reading between the lines. We choose to meander through a work, sometimes weighing each sentence word by word, deriving several posible meanings in the quest for precision. (What a contrast to the regimen of timed texts and the single right answer.) We teachers demonstrate our belief in an unique way of reading and knowing the world to our students so that they in turn will come to value and respect language.

Although we share this commonality in the way we value critical reading, writing, and thinking, we are hardly like-minded as members of the National Council of Teachers of English. The origin of NCTE was built on protest and dissent. In 1911 the founding group reacted against the imposition on secondary schools of uniform college reading lists accompanied by a blanket college curriculum for all students. This edict from “higher” education affected “. . .tens of thousands of [students] from foreign families who knew so little English that the current prescription was entirely useless.” Does this sound all too familiar? Indeed, today the debate continues as state high school exit examinations have proliferated, many requiring college content knowledge of every secondary student in order to pass.

From John Holt, “How Teachers Make Students Hate Reading.” 1967

(After talking about how he told his fifth grade class that they could read “anything they wanted,” Holt tells of a girl who went back and read below-grade level books for the first month, then progressed as the year wore on . . .)

During the spring she really astonished me, however. One day, in one of our many free periods, she was reading at her desk. From a glimpse of the illustrations I thought I knew what the book was. I said to myself, “It can’t be,” and went to take a closer look. Sure enough, she was reading Moby Dick, in the edition with woodcuts by Rockwell Kent. When I came close to her desk, she looked up. I said, “Are you really reading that?” She said she was. I said, “Do you like it?” She said, “Oh, yes, it’s neat!” I said, “Don’t you find parts of it rather heavy going?” She answered, “Oh, sure, but I just skip over those parts and go on to the next good part”

This is exactly what reading should be and in school so seldom is—an exciting, joyous adventure. Find something, dive into it, take the good parts, skip the bad parts, get what you can out of it, go on to something else. How different is our mean-spirited, picky insistence that every child get every last little scrap of “understanding” that can be dug out of a book.

Unfortunately, we English teachers are easily hung up on this matter of understanding. Why should children understand everything they read? Why should anyone? Does anyone? I don’t, and I never did. I was always reading books that teachers would have said were “too hard” for me, books full of words I didn’t know. That’s how I got to be a good reader. When about ten, I read all the D’Artagnan stories and loved them. It didn’t trouble me in the least that I didn’t know why France was at war with England or who was quarreling with whom in the French court, or why the Musketeers should always be at odds with Cardinal Richelieu’s men. I didn’t even know who the Cardinal was, except that he was a dangerous and powerful man that my friends had to watch out for. This was all I needed to know.

From the Introduction to Perrine’s Story and Structure, 10th edition, Thomas Arp and Greg Johnson, Eds. 2002.

This tenth edition of Perrine’s Story and Structure, like the previous editions, is written for the student who is beginning a serious study of fiction. It seeks to give that student a sufficient grasp of the nature and variety of fiction, some reasonable means for reading it with appreciative understanding, and a few primary ideas of how to evaluate it. The separate chapters gradually introduce the student to the elements of fiction, putting the emphasis always on how and why: How can the reader use these elements to get at the meaning of the story, to interpret it correctly, and to respond to it adequately? Why does the writer use these elements? What values have they for the writer and the reader?

. . . We all know how we feel when we first read through a story. We probably start by thinking “I like this” or “it doesn’t say much to me” or “what in the world is that supposed to mean?” If you could, you’d act on your first reaction and read the story again, or try to see what it’s trying to say, or drop it and go on to do something more pleasurable.

But you’re in a special situation. You’re taking a course (either by your own choice or because you’re required to), and one of the rules of the game is that you’re supposed to move from your initial reaction to some sort of “serious” response that will satisfy your teacher. If you like a story and want to reread it, your teacher will pester you with wanting to know why you like it, and might even insist that you offer reasons why other people should like it too. If you are only a little bit curious about it or think that it is a waste of your time, your teacher will lead (or nudge, or bash) you into finding things in the story that might change your first opinion. In any case, the terms of your special situation, as a student in a course with a grade on the horizon, make it necessary for you have more than an initial reaction. You’ll need to have a developing understanding of the story and you’ll need to show in discussion or writing both what you understand and how the story led to that understanding.

From “Total Effect and the Eighth Grade” by Flannery O’Connor. 1963.

In other ages the attention of children was held by Homer and Virgil, among others, but, by the reverse evolutionary process, that is no longer possible; our children are too stupid now to enter the past imaginatively. No one asks the student if algebra pleases him or if he finds it satisfactory that some French verbs are irregular, but if he prefers Hersey to Hawthorne, his taste must prevail.

No child needs to be assigned Hersey or Steinbeck until he is familiar with a certain amount of the best work of Cooper, Hawthorne, Melville, the early James, and Crane [we can quibble with the names; I certainly quibble with Cooper�s inclusion], and he does not need to be assigned these until he has been introduced to some of the better English novelists of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.

The fact that these works do not present him with the realities of his own time is all to the good. He is surrounded by the realities of his own time, and he has no perspective whatever from which to view them. Like the college student who wrote in her paper on Lincoln that he went to the movies and got shot, many students go to college unaware that the world was not made yesterday; their studies began with the present and dipped backward occasionally when it seemed necessary or unavoidable.

The high-school English teacher will be fulfilling his responsibility if he furnishes the student a guided opportunity, through the best writing of the past, to come, in time, to an understanding of the best writing of the present. He will teach literature, not social studies or little lessons in democracy or the customs of many lands.

And if the student finds that this is not to his taste? Well, that is regrettable. Most regrettable. His taste should not be consulted; it is being formed.

DMU Timestamp: March 26, 2020 18:18





Image
0 comments, 0 areas
add area
add comment
change display
Video
add comment

Quickstart: Commenting and Sharing

How to Comment
  • Click icons on the left to see existing comments.
  • Desktop/Laptop: double-click any text, highlight a section of an image, or add a comment while a video is playing to start a new conversation.
    Tablet/Phone: single click then click on the "Start One" link (look right or below).
  • Click "Reply" on a comment to join the conversation.
How to Share Documents
  1. "Upload" a new document.
  2. "Invite" others to it.

Logging in, please wait... Blue_on_grey_spinner