NowComment
2-Pane Combined
Comments:
Full Summaries Sorted

Voices in the Wilderness (The Treatment Trap, Chapter 1)

Author: Rosemary Gibson and Janardan Prasad Singh

0 General Document comments
0 Sentence and Paragraph comments
0 Image and Video comments


It was 1998, and the truth was coming out. In Washington, D.C., the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences convened a prestigious group of physicians, nurses, and consumers who acknowledged a uniquely American characteristic of our healthcare system. They called the phenomenon "overuse" and said it occurs when the potential for harm of a health-care service exceeds the possible benefit.

New Conversation
Paragraph 1 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 1, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 1, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 1, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

What exactly is overuse? It happens when people have surgery even though their medical condition does not warrant it. It is the revolving door of seemingly benign yet unnecessary tests and office visits that can stir an avalanche of still more tests and procedures. It is the rendering of treatment when no evidence exists that it will yield a benefit.

New Conversation
Paragraph 2 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 2, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 2, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 2, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 2, Sentence 4 0
profile_photo
Apr 11
Christa Mullen (Apr 11 2011 4:05PM) : Why subject yourself to costly, annoying treatments that may not procure any benefits? more

If it is highly possible that the patient will not reap any benefits from the treatments that would be costly – and most likely annoying considering there would supposedly be a lot of them -, why would the patient be willing to put himself or herself through those treatments?
Obviously, desperation is one reason, but could there be any others?

profile_photo

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

Apr 11
Dan Doernberg

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

(Apr 11 2011 5:01PM) : People have lots of reasons not to question doctors [Edited] more
1. When people are sick they want to believe the doctor has the knowledge and motivation to cure them… most don’t even want to contemplate that their doctor is fallible or could have financial incentives to give them less than perfect care.

2. Doctors have high social status and lots of technical education, two things that intimidate people and make then leery of asking questions.

The phenomenon began to be noticed in the 1970s when Dr. John Wennberg, a physician and pioneer in research on differences in health-care use among communities around the country, observed an epidemic of tonsillectomies in Vermont. His research showed that in the town of Stowe, 70 percent of the children had their tonsils removed by the time they were fifteen years old, compared with only 20 percent of children in Waterbury. Wennberg wrote, "For half a century, the tonsil has been the target of a large-scale, uncontrolled surgical experiment tonsillectomy."

New Conversation
Paragraph 3 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 3, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 3, Sentence 2 0
profile_photo
Apr 11
Christa Mullen (Apr 11 2011 3:59PM) : Where were the children's parents? more

One must wonder why so many children’s parents would allow their children to be subjected to a treatment that wasn’t even necessary.

profile_photo

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

Apr 11
Dan Doernberg

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

(Apr 11 2011 5:07PM) : If they knew it was unnecessary (and often harmful) they would say something more

But… there are the emotional reasons above not to challenge doctors, plus the parents don’t have the knowledge about outcomes of (for example) surgery vs. no surgery for a particular condition.

So..or even when they have their childrens’ best interest there are powerful motivations, and no rational knowledge base, to challenge the doctors.

I do think that as there’s more medical information available on the Internet some unnecessary things that used to happen a lot may not happen as much… but maybe news of experimental and alternative treatments just adds to the number of unnecessary things people have heard of that they may ask for!

New Conversation
Paragraph 3, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

Wennberg discovered another epidemic, affecting men in Maine. Sixty percent of men who lived in certain communities had their prostates removed by the time they were age eighty, while only 20 percent of men had the surgery if they lived elsewhere in the state.

New Conversation
Paragraph 4 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 4, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 4, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

In the U.S. Congress in 1974 the House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce held hearings on unnecessary surgery. Experts testified that nearly 18 percent of surgeries they studied might not have been necessary. In 1976 a House Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations heard evidence and concluded that 2.4 million unnecessary surgeries were performed annually, resulting in 11,900 deaths. The annual cost of these surgeries was estimated at $3.9 billion. Since 1976, no new estimate of overuse has been calculated.

New Conversation
Paragraph 5 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 5, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 5, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 5, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 5, Sentence 4 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 5, Sentence 5 0
profile_photo
Apr 11
Christa Mullen (Apr 11 2011 4:13PM) : Why has no one bothered to make any new calculations? more

I suppose having an actual estimation isn’t exactly necessary, considering many people are aware of the overuse problem and considering that knowing that how many are affected will not change the fact that they are being negatively affected. However, I would be curious to know how the estimations would have changed since 1976 and why no one has bothered to keep track of them, or if they have, why they haven’t made it public knowledge.

profile_photo

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

Apr 11
Dan Doernberg

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

(Apr 11 2011 5:03PM) : It is surprising that it hasn't been re-calculated in 35 years! [Edited]

In the 1980s and 1990s the Rand Corporation and other researchers studied the overuse of selected medical procedures and found that many people had surgeries and tests they did not need. One of the procedures they examined was endoscopy, a most unpleasant examination in which the patient swallows a thin, flexible, lighted tube, called an endoscope, which then transmits a picture of the esophagus and stomach from the inside. Seventeen percent of endoscopies were performed for clearly inappropriate reasons.

New Conversation
Paragraph 6 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 6, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 6, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 6, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

The term "overuse" was first coined in 1991 by Dr. Mark Chassin, a physician and researcher, and now president of the Joint Commission, the Chicago-based organization that accredits and certifies sixteen thousand health-care organizations. In an article in the Journal of the American Medical Association, he defined it as providing a treatment when its risk of harm exceeds its potential benefit. At last a growing phenomenon in American health care had a name.

New Conversation
Paragraph 7 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 7, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 7, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 7, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

Although there was ample evidence of too much medicine, it did not arouse concern among the public, the medical establishment, or policymakers. "I feel as if I am a voice in the wilderness," says Dr. James Weinstein of Dartmouth, who has conducted extensive research on unnecessary back surgery. "Theres a Latin phrase for it, 'Vox clamantis in deserto,' a voice shouting in the desert or wilderness."

New Conversation
Paragraph 8 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 8, Sentence 1 0
profile_photo
Apr 11
Christa Mullen (Apr 11 2011 4:20PM) : How could such a thing not arouse concern? more

One must wonder how it is possible that none of those groups of people were concerned. The public would have been the ones who could have died from receiving a surgery they didn’t need as well as the ones spending what could have been hundreds or thousands of dollars on a needless surgery. Plus, the medical establishment and the policymakers had an obligation to see to the safety of those individuals receiving surgeries.

profile_photo

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

Apr 11
Dan Doernberg

I’m the head/founder of Fairness.com LLC. We really hope you … (more)

(Apr 11 2011 5:14PM) : I agree, quite surprising. more

Probably some people didn’t believe the results, others thought a certain amount of cheating and incompetence just happens, and others (those inside the medical system) didn’t want to see the system changed since they were making money from the status quo.

Also… most people don’t like change and don’t want to admit to doing things badly… they’d prefer to avoid acknowledging the problem rather than admit there was a problem and then have to spend time and money and emotional energy fighting to get things fixed.

New Conversation
Paragraph 8, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 8, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

In recent years, however, overuse has gained media attention. Wall Street Journal front-page headline reported new studies that "hint at overuse" of stents to open clogged arteries. The New York Times reported on Elyria, Ohio, where the number of angioplasty procedures performed to open clogged arteries was four times the national average.

New Conversation
Paragraph 9 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 9, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 9, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 9, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

When Jane Brody, the veteran personal health columnist for the Times, described her painful experience with knee surgery, an orthopedic surgeon responded that his boss at his hospital complained that he didn't perform enough surgeries to bring in sufficient revenue. Brody wrote, "This is outrageous and just reveals the monetary motivation behind much of modern medicine. The patient be damned; just bring in the bucks."

New Conversation
Paragraph 10 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 10, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 10, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 10, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

Local newspapers provide a hometown flavor about overuse. In Hilton Head, South Carolina, the Island Packet reported on a whistle-blower lawsuit filed by a physician at Hilton Head Regional Medical Center accusing a physician colleague of performing hundreds of unnecessary heart catheterizations. The accused physician reportedly fled the country, possibly to Canada or Saudi Arabia.

New Conversation
Paragraph 11 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 11, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 11, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 11, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

The Miami Herald reported on a whistle-blower case brought by an anesthesiologist in which a neurosurgeon was prosecuted by the U.S. attorney for performing more than 150 unnecessary back surgeries. The Minot (North Dakota) Daily News described a lawsuit filed by a woman who accused a physician of performing an unnecessary lung surgery. That same month the Victoria (Texas) Advocate published an article, "Are Doctor's Morals for Sale?" quoting local doctors who claimed that their peers were performing excessive and needless tests and procedures "simply to make a buck." The newspaper alleged that "insured Victorians are being fleeced."

New Conversation
Paragraph 12 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 12, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 12, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 12, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 12, Sentence 4 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

Consumer advocacy organizations have joined the voices in the wilderness to forge a path toward a more reasonable use of medical care. Debra Ness, president of the National Partnership for Women and Families, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit group that advocates for better health care, told a U.S. Senate committee, "Unnecessary care is rampant."

New Conversation
Paragraph 13 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 13, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 13, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

What lies beneath the news reports, congressional testimony, and health statistics? What happens to the people? A closer look reveals the untold human story.

New Conversation
Paragraph 14 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 14, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 14, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Conversation
Paragraph 14, Sentence 3 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

DMU Timestamp: April 11, 2011 12:47

General Document Comments 0
Start a new Document-level conversation

Image
0 comments, 0 areas
add area
add comment
change display
Video
add comment

Quickstart: Commenting and Sharing

How to Comment
  • Click icons on the left to see existing comments.
  • Desktop/Laptop: double-click any text, highlight a section of an image, or add a comment while a video is playing to start a new conversation.
    Tablet/Phone: single click then click on the "Start One" link (look right or below).
  • Click "Reply" on a comment to join the conversation.
How to Share Documents
  1. "Upload" a new document.
  2. "Invite" others to it.

Logging in, please wait... Blue_on_grey_spinner