NowComment
2-Pane Combined
Comments:
Full Summaries Sorted

Guidelines for Supporting CRSE Aligned to Danielson's Rubric

Author: Liz Locatelli and Bena Kallick

Linking Components of the CRSE Initiative with the Danielson Rubric

This chart is designed to show how we might support the whole child by embedding CRSE into teaching practices.

WHY

HOW

WHAT

Notes

Culturally Responsive

Academic Mindset

Instructional Strategies

Academic Focus

Belonging – students feel part of the design process & the learning community

Ownership – students are invested because they helped create expectations

Co-creation- students work with classmates and teacher to design products/performances and success criteria

Clear Expectations

Learning Targets

Checklists

Anchors to analyze together

Growth Mindsetstudents see that they get better with effort

Self-Efficacystudents believe they can succeed because they see where they are & where they need to go.

Social Construction students work together to deepen learning, explore ideas, and help each other to achieve success

Voicestudents show their thinking periodically

Feedback – students receive timely, actionable feedback they can use

Formative Assessments

Various types

Ongoing

Actionable Feedback

Opportunities to improve

Self-Discovery- students pursue interests; they also learn about themselves as learners so that they can take responsibility for the learning.

Empowermentstudents see that their voices make a difference

Voice students are invited to share their thinking and ideas

Social Construction students work together to, deepen learning, explore ideas/ and achieve success

Authentic Assessments

Choices

Audience

Purpose

Complexity

A sample K-5 to Clarify the connection between CRSE and Lesson Planning
This chart is designed to show one way that CRSE might be built into a lesson plan; any lesson design can accomplish the same thing as long as teachers pay attention to the Elements of Personalized Learning: Voice, Co-Creation, Social Construction and Self-Discovery.

Learning Opportunities

CRSE/HOM Connections

Students listen and look at pictures in Drawn Together by Minh Lee; they stop periodically to discuss how they think the boy is feeling and support their inferences with:

  1. their own experiences and feelings
  2. specific words or details in the pictures

Voice: Students are given a voice as they share relevant experiences and observations. As students hear different perspectives, they build Cultural Intelligence. They also see that what they already know and can do has value and can help them to succeed.

Applying Past Knowledge to New Situations

Students talk with peers to ask and answer questions they have about the story and to list things that made the book interesting and meaningful to them.

Social Construction: Students work together to deepen learning or understanding of a text/topic through their own inquiry. Questioning and Posing Problems

Students create pictures to show a challenge they faced and how they solved it.

Students have a choice in what to present and how to present it. This activity also focuses attention on Social/Emotional Learning. Creating, Imagining and Innovating

They share their pictures and tell the story to a peer(s) who will ask clarifying questions.

Social construction: Students act as a learning community where members share their ideas and support each other in refining their thinking and communication. By questioning, students show interest in each other’s stories and learn from each other’s experiences. Thinking & Communicating with Clarity & Precision

They highlight what they liked in the shared work & use those models to create learning targets, checklists or guidelines for revising their stories.

Co-Creation: Students share their thinking about what works best and work together to establish success criteria that will help them to improve. Thinking Interdependently

Students use the work done with peers to add text to explain the pictures more fully.

Students use learning targets/checklists to check progress, make sure the work is complete/accurate; they take responsibility for learning. Striving for Accuracy

Students share their stories with classmates who ask questions and make connections to their own experiences.

Voice: Students feel heard and respected; they also build Cultural Intelligence by hearing the various experiences and perspectives of their peers.
Listening with Understanding and Empathy

Students create Learning Pit Charts to show feelings they had as they worked through the task. They annotate what made them feel that way.

Self-Discovery: Students learn about themselves as learners; this empowers them to take more responsibility in later tasks. Thinking About Your Thinking

Connecting CR-SE with the Danielson Rubric

Teacher__________________________ Class_______________ Date______

Domain 1: Planning and Preparation
This chart is designed to give you a sense of the type of questions you might ask to determine what a teacher understands and is doing to engage in CRSE. It is NOT a checklist, but rather gives you entry points for an open discussion. You can select one or more questions to pursue or create your own. You might use the Notes column to identify teachers who are integrating CRSE successfully and might support their colleagues.

Possible Questions to build CRSE awareness during pre-observations:

Notes

What resources might enable students to view concepts, issues, themes, social problems from several multi-cultural perspectives?

What systems and/or protocols might encourage students to share experiences, feelings, and perspectives during the lesson? (ex. accountable talk stems, discussion protocols, group roles, etc.)

What choices might students make during the learning so that they develop a sense of ownership and have opportunities to use their strengths to demonstrate learning?

What assessments might you build into the lesson so that you can monitor and support each student’s progress?

How might you scaffold activities so that students believe they can succeed?

How might you involve students as co-creators in the creation/ analysis/ reflections of performance task(s) and assessment criteria (ex. rubric, check-list, etc.)?

_________________________________________________________

Domain 2: Classroom Environment

The charts for Domains 2 & 3 represent just a sample of the ways in which teachers might incorporate CRSE into the classroom environment or their practice. You might circle the items you notice and add others which are not on this list but provide evidence of CRSE in a class. This chart can be used to collect data that will allow you to share best practices through inter-visitations.

Some of what you might see in a culturally responsive classroom

Notes/Other

On the classroom walls/boards/shelves, you might look for:

explicit learning targets written in student-friendly language

classroom expectations that give all students a sense of belonging

class commitments and/or agreements established as a community

samples of student work that show a variety of styles/levels of performance

student work that shows students’ own identities

comments on students’ work that have been made by their peers

signs and symbols of Habits of Mind integrated into class norms, culture, and learning

_____________________________________________________

In a walkthrough/observation, you might look for teachers’ inviting students to share:

how they are feeling about themselves, the content or learning tasks

how their personal experiences help them to make sense of the text/content

what interests or confuses them about a task and where they might seek additional information or assistance prior to asking a teacher

strategies they might use to complete a task or overcome setbacks

___________________________________________________

In a walkthrough/observation, you might look for:

students supporting each other in developing the Habit of Mind. For example, students gently remind each other of strategies that might help in a given situation.

students using the language of the Habits of Mind as they explain how they are proceeding, improving, or completing a task.

students independently defining/articulating a problem, idea, design, or investigation they want to pursue.
___________________

Domain 3: Instruction

Some of what you might see in a culturally responsive environment

Notes/Other

During a class observation/walk-through, you might look for:

students listening to each other’s suggestions as they discuss which options they would like to pursue Listening with Understanding and Empathy

students asking questions that require higher levels of thinking and working together to find answers Questioning and posing problems

students using anchors/drafts that represent a variety of styles and levels of performance to co-create success criteria which can be used to monitor their progress Thinking Interdependently

students articulating how they learn best and the kind of help they need from peers/teacher on a particular task Thinking about Their Thinking

students giving each other meaningful feedback, based on clear success criteria Thinking and Communicating with Clarity and Precision

During a class discussion you might look for:

students expressing ideas/feelings in a variety of ways Taking Responsible Risks

students respectfully pausing, paraphrasing & probing to understand the ideas of others Listening with Understanding & Empathy

students asking peers to explain statements or to cite textual references
Striving for Accuracy

students questioning and seeking answers that move them more deeply
into the learning Questioning and Posing Problems

In talking with students, you might see how they are Thinking about Their Thinking by asking them to explain:

what they are doing/learning and why

where they are in the learning process and what they need to do next

how they are using feedback/success criteria to improve their work

how they feel about their progress and ability to succeed

which strategies/Habits of Mind are helping or might help them to succeed

DMU Timestamp: March 22, 2022 17:05





Image
0 comments, 0 areas
add area
add comment
change display
Video
add comment

Quickstart: Commenting and Sharing

How to Comment
  • Click icons on the left to see existing comments.
  • Desktop/Laptop: double-click any text, highlight a section of an image, or add a comment while a video is playing to start a new conversation.
    Tablet/Phone: single click then click on the "Start One" link (look right or below).
  • Click "Reply" on a comment to join the conversation.
How to Share Documents
  1. "Upload" a new document.
  2. "Invite" others to it.

Logging in, please wait... Blue_on_grey_spinner