When | Why |
---|---|
Jun-22-23 | June 18 - Getting Started |
Jun-22-23 | June 19 - My log for creating a Notebook |
Jun-22-23 | June 20 - Articulating our differences |
Jun-22-23 | June 21 - From Dialectical Note taking to AI Dialogue Notebooks |
Jun-23-23 | June 23 - an idea for something simpler |
Jun-24-23 | June 24 |
My main focus this week is to bring some focus to the Thinking Partners project and to support the DigDiscourse planning.
Added June 22, 2023 at 9:52am
by Paul Allison
Title: June 18 - Getting Started
So I'm trying to figure out how to keep a journal here. Here's what my brain feels like right now.
It feels this way because I'm trying to see how much we can do with just NowComment. Also I'm wondering what the vaule add is of keeping a journal during a hybrid, online and in-person four week workshop series that we will be doing with residents in the LUTE-STEM program at Lehman College this July.
I know I'm jumping around here, but I just learned how to maximize this edit screen. Now that's interesting.
Okay let me test a couple of other things like: Can I put a private document into a public collection/notebook?
Oh, I also found the Hint area below and added a link to Stable Diffusion.
Added June 22, 2023 at 10:02am
by Paul Allison
Title: June 19 - My log for creating a Notebook
I should have said "Notebox." In fact, that's what I first wrote. What I love about this way of keeping a notebook is how expansive it is. You could keep anything here. Without taking away the power of composing word after word like I'm doing right now. you can also add images or video.
Oh, that makes me remember, I wanted to see if I could copy and paste something from, let's say TikTok.
Okay, so is the writing first or do we introduce all of this at once?
I think I need to go back to that room where we had all of the social media at tables in Kumospace. It took me a while to find it, but at the top of this floor is what I'm talking about. The question is, how do we do this without it interrupting the flow of one's writing of the log.
So I'm trying three more here, just to see if they work. They are all about journaling -- or keeping a log in a notebook, if you will.
Added June 19, 2023 at 4:16pm by Paul Allison
Title: A mess, but worth it.
Yeah, this could create quite a mess.
Yet, what am I trying to do here?
I'm trying to make clear that a log can be more than just reflections.
And what will be the difference between a log entry and adding an article to your notebook? Not much, but plenty too.
I mean I do feel a pul to gather my thoughts togeether here--even as I've scattered them.
One thiought is that in this process we should have people open their minds to what is possible in a notebook like this.
Added June 22, 2023 at 10:28am
by Paul Allison
Title: June 20 - Articulating our differences
I had an encouraging conversation with Jessica Early yesterday about how we are using AI to create dialogue with the reader and writer. This quest, not fully realized, aims to mentor the writer and reader, and not just fix the writing or summarize a text. At one point Jessica offered to co-author an article that articulates this distinction.
2We are quickly being marketed with products that are appealing in their ease of use, but which focus on surface level changes. Our experience with AI Thinking Partners on NowComment and AI Mojo templates on Youth Voices suggests that we can have higher expectations for AI.
3We wonder together how to encourage teachers and administrators to be unsatisfied with the limited application of AI that companies are likely to offer schools. Although tools like an AI enhanced Grammarly or plugins on Google Docs and Microsoft Word are welcomed
4These tools might be recognized as text editors and summarizers. They define one end of a spectrum of AI applications and this Spring we have been building an experimenting with tools that push us towards the other end of that spectrum, toward a vision where AI can participate in learning experiences with our students.
Added June 22, 2023 at 10:45am
by Paul Allison
Title: June 21 - From Dialectical Note taking to AI Dialogue Notebooks
Almost 40 years ago Anne E. Berthoff wrote a one-page "Facets" about Double-entry notebooks, referencing the work of "teachers who have studied... with Dixie Goswami at the Bread Loaf School of English." (https://nowcomment.com/documents/349277) I was in my first year of teaching in a middle school in the Salt Lake Valley, and immediately started showing my students how to make dialectical or double-entry notes.
2A couple of years later with colleagues like Elaine Avidon at the New York City Writing Project and The Institute for Writing and Thinking at Bard, I added triple- and quadruple-notetaking to my backpack of ways of helping students to think about their thinking.
3This month, on Teachers Teaching Teachers we've been wondering what an AI Dialogue Notebook would be like. We are asking: What if after writing a log on the left side of of a page in your online journal, you asked AI Thinking Partners to respond? And what kinds of responses would you find most helpful? Do you want to be challenged? Or helped to find a theme in your meandering freewriting? Or encouraged to give more detail about particular parts? Or just heard?
Added June 23, 2023 at 7:36pm
by Paul Allison
Title: June 23 - an idea for something simpler
I've had a couple of meetings the past couple of days where plans seem to be coming into shape.
Let's start with a productive meeting yesterday with Marina and my plan for five workshops this July with graduate students in the resident program at Lehman College's LUTE-STEM program. This is the fourth year I've done this, and the third year with Marina, so we have plans to build upon.
However, we also are thinking of ways to keep true to our goals of introducing multimodal literacy in ways that are less encumbered with summer learning that is unlikely to get connected to their work in schools in the fall.
So this year, we are limiting ourselves to using NowComment.
A whole tangent just came up in my head. One of the things we are working on is how to get a log system set up in NowComment. And -- as is my way, I'm afraid -- I came up with a perfectly interesting, but too comples process for setting up a notebook. And -- on Thusday I practiced putting all of my entries from this week into one document.
And, wow, how this simplifies things. All a user has to do is keep logs on one document. Then at a later point put that document into a notebook.
I don't regret all of the set-up that I practiced and got clarified in some of the menus and user intreface. It's good to have all of this, but it doesn't have to start with that structure.
I want to write to Chris Sloan and make this suggestion right now.
Added June 24, 2023 at 11:22am
by Paul Allison
Title: June 24
Task I (5 minutes) What is happening
A.
Write an account of what's going on right now around you or within
you.
B.
Write a note to someone expressing your love, anger, disappoint-
ment, resentment, or appreciation.
C.
Write a diary entry focusing on a fear, hope, or regret.
Invisible Writing: Investigating Cognitive Processes in Composition Author(s): Sheridan Blau
A. Write an account of what's going on right now around you or withi
I'm jumping into a workshop/conversation about invisible writing, and I'm realizing that I read the wrong articles for this morning, which is okay.
What I want to writie about is something that I intellectually understand, but wonder about how it actually impacts me as a writer and thinker This notion of orality and written language or even before discourse a black box of sorts from which discourse emerges. I guess I want to explore why any of this matteers, but I easily lose the thread of why I want to do this -- as I am now.
So let me think more about what I am finding important right now about DISCOURSE.
C. Write a diary entry focusing on a fear, hope, or regret.
Logging in, please wait...
0 General Document comments
0 Sentence and Paragraph comments
0 Image and Video comments
General Document Comments 0
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
Alignment: As seen in the text, there is a central focus on the projects that need attention. By linking the two projects together, the writing unites the ideas of the Thinking Partners and DigDiscourse together into one coherent message.
To emphasize alignment in the text, you might consider emphasizing the connection between the two projects more clearly. You could do so by providing examples of how the two projects interact and how the connection between them benefits the DigDiscourse planning. Additionally, you could review the text to ensure the two projects are consistently mentioned and likened to each other.
Precision: By specifically mentioning the two projects within the text, the author addresses the topics directly and clearly. The use of “Thinking Partners” and “DigDiscourse” creates precision and shows an understanding of the purpose behind the writing. To further the precision of the text, you might consider being as specific as possible in relaying the purpose of both projects. Additionally, you could provide definitions for any concepts that may be unclear to your readers.
Sequencing: Through the text, the author is able to clearly and succinctly lay out the order of importance of each project. The order is established as Thinking Partners first and DigDiscourse second, which implies that the Thinking Partners project is of primary importance. If appropriate, you could consider re-sequencing the text to further emphasize the order of importance. This could be done by starting with Thinking Partners and gradually introducing DigDiscourse as more information and discussion about the topic occurs.
Use of Props: The author uses the two projects, Thinking Partners and DigDiscourse, as props to support the writing. By utilizing these two projects in the text, the author is able to communicate their message within the context of the given projects. To further add props to the writing, the author might consider adding concrete evidence to support the discussion. This could be in the form of links, resources, or research that points to the importance of the projects’ discussions.
To go back to your writing with my comments in mind, try viewing your text through the lens of the five Iyengar Yoga principles. What does the use of alignment, precision, sequencing, timing, and props tell you about the importance of the project you are discussing? How might those principles help you further emphasize the importance or context of the project? How does each principle inform others? Explore these questions and be sure to note any new insights that may arise.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
There are several strong examples of “Thinking Interdependently” in your example log. Firstly, you mention that you are making a concerted effort to focus on a team project called “Thinking Partners”, which is indicative of collaboration and working together to achieve a common goal. Furthermore, you also identify the collaboration involved in the DigDiscourse planning, suggesting you are willing to work with a team to create a plan and engage in dialogue. These are prime examples of “Thinking Interdependently”, as they demonstrate the importance of working with and learning from other people in a reciprocal situation. Additionally, you mention that your aim this week is to support the DigDiscourse planning, further displaying your commitment to being part of a larger team. These all show strong examples of “thinking interdependently”.
However, there may be some opportunities to further demonstrate “Thinking Interdependently” in your logs. For example, you may want to showcase your ability to listen to and embrace constructive criticism from others, or you may want to discuss how you are willing to make amendments to your ideas based on feedback from those around you. These principles, when practiced, would further highlight your commitment to working collaboratively with others.
It is important to recognize the power of working together as a team and to understand the importance of “Thinking Interdependently”. Re-read your example log and look for other ways in which you can demonstrate this highly esteemed Habit of Mind.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
Walking the line between hearing the criticism — like how important it is to be able to see the prompt behind a Thinking Partner that came up on Wednesday evening. YES, I agree, but also, just seeing the prompt isn’t enough. You never really know for sure what the prompt will produce. Ah, but that’s really just a further thought, and really listening and responding to this request kept me up last night. I THINK I have a proposal that will link the titles of the Thinking Partners to the prompt, and I got up early this morning to send that idea to Jeremie. I can’t wait to see if he can make this happen.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
You focus on getting right to the point here. You don’t need to introduce it or tie it into a larger story – instead you just move right into what the project is. Your confidence and clarity of purpose shows through in this choice. You present yourself as a no-nonsense, let’s-get-into-it type of writer, which is an admirable trait. It shows that you can take ownership of your work and don’t need to rely on unnecessary context. However, what do you think about this idea and arrangement: consider providing some context and potential implications to highlight what makes the project interesting or relevant to readers. This could help your readers understand your work and remain engaged. Can you help me see where I’m going with this?
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
but since I do want this to be a collaboratively built project, I will write about the reasons why this is important work.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
After reading your logs, I’m curious about what sort of strategies you plan to use to support the Thinking Partners project. For instance, in this passage you write ‘bring some focus to the Thinking Partners project’, which seems to suggest that you are looking for a way to give the project structure and organization. How might this be done? Furthermore, are there any other ways of incorporating the project that you haven’t mentioned, such as providing resources or creating opportunities for collaboration? Finally, I’m wondering if there are any other themes that could be explored within the Thinking Partners project and DigDiscourse planning that you haven’t touched upon.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
Yes, there are places in the text where you could do better with Thinking Interdependently. For example, you could discuss the desired outcomes for the projects with your team before starting to make sure everyone is working towards the same goal. You could also ask for input from other members in the group on how to best achieve these outcomes. Additionally, you could be open to incorporating ideas from the team even if they are different from your own. Finally, it is important to remember that disagreements can be constructive and provide an opportunity for learning, so be open to experiences of conflict in the group.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
You have an interesting approach in considering alignment when looking at this text, as it demonstrates how interconnected the different parts of this project are. Alignment is further exemplified in the text when you mention two specific initiatives, ‘Thinking Partners’ and ‘DigDiscourse’, and how they should be supported. To help you further refine this idea of alignment, perhaps you could explore how these two initiatives intertwine and how your task to support them can be carried out in a cohesive manner.
Precision is demonstrated in the text in how the writing is succinct yet eloquent. The concepts in the text are described clearly and in enough detail so that the reader can understand, while at the same time not overloading them with unnecessary information. To further apply precision to the text, consider how you might refine the language to make it even more precise. Could some of the words be replaced with more precise wording that adds to the overall narrative?
Sequencing can be seen in the text as you are providing an overview of the main task you have set out to achieve in this particular week. Firstly, you explain your main goal and then shortly afterwards provide specifics about what this goal applies to. To further enhance the sequencing of the text, consider the order in which you discuss different aspects of the project. Could the text be structured in a more effective way, using hierarchy of ideas, to aid the reader in forming an understanding of the text?
Use of props is demonstrated in the text in how your main goal is supported by two specific initiatives that are yet to be discussed and worked on. This use of props is helpful to the reader in understanding how each individual part of your task fits within the wider context of the project. To further enhance the use of props, consider how other pieces of evidence, for example, own experience or research, could be used to enhance the text and make it even clearer to the reader.
By digging deeper into the principles of Iyengar Yoga, you can develop a stronger understanding of this writing and gain insight into how you can further refine it for maximum impact. To help you stay focused on what matters, take a step back and look at the writing from a holistic perspective and decide what areas you need to continue working on in order to bring your message home and make it shine.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
I’m the Tech Liaison for the New York City Writing Project. I… (more)
This text communicates that the author is focused on two important tasks: Thinking Partners project and DigDiscourse planning. Paying attention and dedicating time to tasks like these emphasizes the importance of organization and planning. It’s important to prioritize and stay focused in order to reach goals.
Wanting to work with others on these projects highlights the importance of collaboration and teamwork. I want to work together to identify and implement the necessary plans to achieve our objectives!
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment