NowComment
2-Pane Combined
Comments:
Full Summaries Sorted

Paul's Logs November 16 - 22

3 additions to document , most recent about 1 year ago

When Why
Nov-16-23 And example of a student's playful interaction with GPT Tutor.
Nov-17-23 Tweeking the prompt for our Figurative Language Monitor
Nov-18-23 Asking Skloot for ideas on my own writing.

Every time I look at my stream of comments on NowComment or in My Library, I'm surprised, challenged, delighted, or in awe, or just pleased with what students are doing with GPT Thinking Partners.

I don't know who the audience will be for this, but I'd like to use my GPT Weekly Logs as a way to report out what I'm seeing.

It's very exciting because it's crowdsourced, and by that I mean what the insights, jokes, understandings the students show would not have happened except for a network of language that starts with the authors that they are reading, connects to their teacher's assignments, conversatioins, explanations, and encouragement, moves to the prompts that I and others have created for the GPTs, and connects to their peers comments, and -- a bit on the side -- gets watched by me. Occassionally I'll change the prompts based on what they are doing with them and how they are responding.

It's quite a network of language interaction and I feel such gratitude to be a part of their learning.

Let me show you some of what I'm going on about! I'll try to do that at least once each day this week and see how it goes.

DMU Timestamp: November 14, 2023 14:50

Added November 16, 2023 at 12:58pm by Paul Allison
Title: And example of a student's playful interaction with GPT Tutor.

No More Elegies Today - Joey

Joey is a ninth grader in Philadelphia

Original private post https://nowcomment.com/documents/362000/twopane

Snow days
Snow days, every kid’s dream
to wake up seeing inches upon inches
of fresh snow outside.
The roads covered in the white dust
That seemed to never end.
No, there aren’t any underlying meanings
hidden beneath the snow
just the pure feeling of happiness
of waking up to a snow day.
Children playing outside in the snow
creating snow angels with their bodies
Helping each other make snowmen and snowwomen
gathering sticks for the arms, rocks for the face
and a carrot for the nose.
Throwing snowballs at each other
screaming with joy
having fun
and spreading laughter.

General Document Comments

profile_photo

Nov 14

Joey L's Question

:

What is my writing style?

Figurative Language Mentor with Joey L's edits:

Hello there! It’s great to see you diving into the world of poetry with such enthusiasm. Your poem “Snow Days” brings to life the joy and excitement that comes with a wintry white canvas. Now, let’s take a closer look at your use of figurative language.

You’ve got a couple of strong uses of figurative language that really resonate with the reader. For example:
1. “The roads covered in the white dust / That seemed to never end.” Here, describing snow as “white dust” is a vivid and original comparison. It evokes a sense of endlessness and peacefulness of the snow-covered landscape, fitting well with the overall theme of your poem.
2. “creating snow angels with their bodies.” This phrase is particularly effective—the image of snow angels connects deeply with the childhood experience of snow days, and the use of the word “creating” emphasizes the active and imaginative play that snow evokes.

However, there’s room to amplify the effectiveness of your figurative language in other places:
1. “every kid’s dream / to wake up seeing inches upon inches / of fresh snow outside.” While this description sets the scene effectively, it isn’t particularly original or unique. Perhaps you could strengthen this visual with a more unexpected comparison, like “a blanket knit by winter’s own hand” or “a marshmallow world swallowing the familiar.”
2. “screaming with joy / having fun / and spreading laughter.” These lines are very literal and don’t offer much in terms of figurative language. Consider painting this happiness with metaphor or simile, perhaps comparing the laughter to a melody that dances through the frosty air, or likening the joyous screams to the vibrant chorus of a wintertime symphony.

Don’t forget that good figurative language should enhance the reader’s experience and give them a new way to think about the world you’re presenting. Keep playing with those comparisons, metaphors, and symbols—I can tell you’ve got a creative spark that’s ready to turn into a delightful literary firework!

Now, why don’t you have a go at reworking those less strong examples or add another couple of lines with fresh figurative language? I can’t wait to see what you come up with—please share your thoughts when you’re ready!

profile_photo

Nov 14

Joey L

:

!!!

It dodged my question completely and started yapping about figurative language like okay we get it you’re a figurative language mentor calm down.

profile_photo

Nov 14

Joey L's Question

:

What do you think of my amazing poem?

Figurative Language Mentor with Joey L's edits:

Hello there! First of all, thank you for sharing your poem with me. It’s such a joy to see you unfolding your thoughts and emotions through words. Snow days do have a special place in everyone’s heart, don’t they? And you’ve captured this feeling quite well in your poem.

Now let’s take a look at your figurative language – you’ve got quite an imaginative approach here!

One strong example of figurative language comes from these lines: “The roads covered in the white dust / That seemed to never end.” Here, describing the snow as “white dust” is effective. It’s original and conveys a sense of endlessness, which resonates well with the theme of boundless joy that snow days bring. Your comparison not only paints a vivid image but also enhances the reader’s understanding of the scene’s expansive nature.

Another powerful moment is: “Children playing outside in the snow / creating snow angels with their bodies.” This is evocative and creates a strong visual image that most readers can easily connect with. The idea of “creating snow angels” uses a lovely and innocent metaphor that aligns perfectly with the carefree happiness you’re depicting. It’s original and clear, and it suitably matches the overall tone of your poem.

However, we could look for opportunities to push your creativity further in a couple of places. For example, the line “gathering sticks for the arms, rocks for the face / and a carrot for the nose,” while descriptive, it tends to relay more of a literal activity. You might want to introduce a bit more figurative language here to add another layer of imagery. Perhaps consider something that invokes motion or emotion, such as “dressing the snow with arms of twiggy embrace, pebble smiles, and a carrot beacon nose.”

Additionally, in the case of “Throwing snowballs at each other / screaming with joy,” you could elevate these lines by using a simile or metaphor to compare the joyous outbursts to something unexpected yet fitting, amplifying the emotional charge of the action. An example might be, “Like stars in fleeting orbits, snowballs cross, trailing giggles in their wake,” giving both a cosmic element and a sense of playfulness to the scene.

What do you think about these suggestions? Could you see how they add depth and layers to your existing description? The great thing about poetry is its elasticity – it can stretch and morph with every revision. If you’re open to it, try tweaking those lines and see where your imagination takes you. And remember, every poem is a new snowy landscape to craft and play in. When you’re ready, I’d be delighted to step back into this winter wonderland with you and explore some more.

profile_photo

Nov 14

Joey L

:

Yay

It actually gave me some solid advice woah!!!

profile_photo

Nov 14

Joey L's Question

:

What is the theme of my poem?

Figurative Language Mentor with Joey L's edits:

Ah, what a delightful poem you’ve brought to the table today! Your theme is rooted in the childlike joy and wonder that accompanies a snow day. It’s a subject that certainly warms the heart and brings a smile to one’s face. Let’s dive into your use of figurative language and see where your imagery builds this mood and where you might be able to add a touch more sparkle, shall we?

First, I must commend you on a line that truly shines: “The roads covered in the white dust / That seemed to never end.” This instance of figurative language is quite strong. The term “white dust” gives snow an ephemeral quality, hinting at something magical and enchanting, heightening the sense of a winter wonderland that stretches infinitely. It’s a beautiful, clear image that serves its purpose with originality and relevance to the theme – well done indeed.

Another strong usage is found in “creating snow angels with their bodies.” Here, the children are not just lying in the snow; they are likened to artists, and the snow becomes their canvas. This metaphor suggests not just play, but creation, aligning well with the theme of joyfulness and creativity inherent in a snow day.

Now, let’s turn our attention to passages where the figurative language could sparkle just a bit more. The line “gathering sticks for the arms, rocks for the face / and a carrot for the nose,” while descriptive, is a touch on the nose (no pun intended). You’ve used direct representation rather than figurative language here. Why not add a metaphor or simile? For example, you might say something like “assembling a guardian of winter with twiggy limbs and a pebble smile, crowned with a carrot beacon.” See how the snowman becomes more than just the sum of its parts; it takes on a life and purpose of its own?

Similarly, “Throwing snowballs at each other / screaming with joy,” is quite direct and could benefit from a dash of metaphor. Perhaps you could frame the snowball fight in a more evocative way: “Launching frosty orbs in a dance of winter’s revelry, their laughter pealing like chimes through the crisp air.” This not only describes the action but enhances the atmosphere with auditory and tactile sensations.

Remember, you have a strong sense of your theme and a natural inclination toward evocative imagery. Lean into these strengths to make every word count and every image pop. Now, I’d love to read your revised lines incorporating this feedback. How would you rephrase them to add more originality and depth to your poem? Let’s continue to mold your poem together, shall we?

profile_photo

Nov 14

Joey L

:

Yippee!!

“Ah, what a delightful poem you’ve brought to the table today!” I agree, my poem truly is a delight to read!!

DMU Timestamp: November 14, 2023 14:50

Added November 17, 2023 at 11:11am by Paul Allison
Title: Tweeking the prompt for our Figurative Language Monitor

profile_photo

Nov 16

Joey L's Question

:

What is my writing style?

Figurative Language Mentor with Joey L's edits:

Hello there! I’m glad we have this opportunity to discuss your writing style, especially through the lens of your figurative language. Remember, our aim here is to explore the question you’ve asked about your writing style, and using figurative language effectively can be a significant aspect of that style.

First off, let’s look at a couple of instances where your figurative language shines. The line “The roads covered in the white dust” is an excellent example of metaphor as it presents snow as “white dust,” which suggests a delicate and light quality to the snowfall, quite fitting to the theme of a snow day. This choice of words engages the reader with a familiar and cozy image.

Another strong instance is in the description, “creating snow angels with their bodies.” Not only is the imagery clear, but the notion of snow angels also brings a sense of innocence and magic to the scene. It reflects the joy and creativity of children and aligns perfectly with your theme of the simple pleasures brought about by snow days.

Now, let’s consider areas with room for enhancement. The phrase “just the pure feeling of happiness of waking up to a snow day,” while it conveys the emotion, could potentially be enriched with metaphoric language. Instead of directly stating “the pure feeling of happiness,” you might consider a metaphor that evokes that emotion through sensory experience, such as “like a surprise gift unwrapping itself to the laughter of the morning.”

Similarly, “screaming with joy” is very direct. While it’s clear, it might be more engaging to show this joy with a fresh simile or metaphor: “voices chiming like bells in a frosty, jubilant concert” – creating a vivid soundscape that depicts the joy of the children without stating it outright.

Remember, the question we’re exploring is about your writing style and how figurative language contributes to it. Balancing directness with figurative expression can create a style that’s both accessible and evocative for your readers.

I encourage you to edit lines, sentences, and paragraphs in your text. If you are the owner of the document, you can double-click on any sentence or paragraph, edit, and update.

Would you like to give it a try? Consider revising one of the lines we discussed. I’m excited to see how you can infuse your work with even more vivid and original figurative language while maintaining clarity and relevance. Feel free to share your revised lines or any new thoughts that this conversation sparks!

profile_photo

Nov 16

Joey L's Question

:

What do you think of my amazing poem?

Figurative Language Mentor with Joey L's edits:

Hello! I’m excited to delve into the world of your poem with you. You’ve written a lovely piece that captures the joy of a snow day, and I’m here to help you reflect on the effectiveness of your figurative language. Remember, the question we’re addressing is: how can your figurative language enhance the reading experience? Let’s explore this together, shall we?

The line “The roads covered in the white dust” is a vivid use of metaphor, which effectively paints a picture of the snow-covered landscape. The term “white dust” adds depth by suggesting a softness and uniform covering, conjuring an almost magical atmosphere. This piece of figurative language is both relevant and clear, contributing positively to the overall atmosphere of your poem.

Moving on, “creating snow angels with their bodies” also stands out as a strong use of imagery. It’s more than just a literal action; it brings to life the whimsical and free-spirited nature of snow days, echoing the playful heart of childhood. The word choice here is original and maintains a consistent tone with the rest of your text, making it a delightful inclusion.

In contrast, consider the line “just the pure feeling of happiness of waking up to a snow day.” Though the sentiment is clear, this line leans towards the literal and could be made more original with the use of figurative language. For instance, you might say, “waking to a world swaddled in silence,” where the word “swaddled” implies comfort and a sense of peace, correlating with happiness in a subtler, more figurative manner.

Similarly, “screaming with joy” directly tells the reader what’s happening, but it might not draw as vivid a picture as it could. How about changing it to something like, “their voices cascading like sunbeams over frosty hills,” to imbue the action with more energy and originality?

As you ponder the question of how to enhance your poem’s figurative language, know that there’s an exciting opportunity to add layers of meaning and sensory details to your work. I encourage you to edit lines, sentences, and paragraphs in your text. If you are the owner of the document, you can double-click on any sentence or paragraph, edit, and update.

Would you be open to experimenting with these suggestions right now? I’d love to see how you weave new threads of figurative language into your poem’s fabric, making it even more captivating. Share any revisions or further reflections you have—the next verse of our conversation awaits your pen!

profile_photo

Nov 16

Joey L's Question

:

What is the theme of my poem?

Figurative Language Mentor with Joey L's edits:

Hello there! Your poem about the simple pleasures of a snow day evokes a lot of warmth and joy, and I can see that you’ve worked to incorporate figurative language that aims to enhance that feeling. As you’ve asked about the theme of your poem, I believe it strongly shines through as the unadulterated happiness and excitement that snow days bring, particularly to children. Now, let’s take a closer look at your use of figurative language according to your criteria, shall we?

Two strong uses of figurative language in your poem are:

1. “The roads covered in the white dust.” Here, you’ve successfully turned an ordinary winter scene into something quite evocative, conveying the quiet and blanketed atmosphere that snow creates. The term “white dust” implies something light and delicate, which fits wonderfully with the theme of the poem, of a world transformed and softened by snow.

2. “Creating snow angels with their bodies.” This is another solid choice. It’s a playful image that virtually everyone can relate to, and within this line lies the magic of transformation – the snow and the children working together to create something beautiful and ephemeral. It’s a figurative description that lifts the reader out of the ordinary, which is entirely consistent with the joyous tone of your poem.

Looking at areas for improvement:

1. The line “No, there aren’t any underlying meanings hidden beneath the snow” might be more powerful with figurative language that shows, rather than tells. For instance, you might rephrase it to something like, “Beneath the snow, no secrets dwell, just the laughter of a day paused in time.” This adds a metaphorical layer that suggests the snow day halts the usual complexities of life, aligning more closely with the notion that the poem’s theme is straightforward and cheery.

2. “Throwing snowballs at each other, screaming with joy,” is direct, but to elevate this with imagery, you could try: “Hurling frosty orbs to burst in laughter’s echo.” This line uses metaphor and personification (frosty orbs, laughter’s echo) to create a more vivid depiction that better captures the exuberance and motion of a snowball fight.

As we reflect on the question of the theme of your poem and how your use of figurative language supports it, these tweaks can make the images you conjure in the reader’s mind even more striking and memorable.

I encourage you to edit lines, sentences, and paragraphs in your text. If you are the owner of the document, you can double-click on any sentence or paragraph, edit and update.

Why not give these suggestions a try and see how they feel alongside the rest of your work? It’s a beautiful dance, the way words can waltz across a page with just a bit of guidance! Feel free to share any new versions or thoughts—in this conversation, every stanza leads to a new discovery.

DMU Timestamp: November 17, 2023 02:49

Added November 18, 2023 at 10:58am by Paul Allison
Title: Asking Skloot for ideas on my own writing.

Paul Allison

:

Ideas for my writing.

profile_photo

Nov 18

Paul Allison's Question

:

Can you talk to me about how you braided your story into the scientific story and the Lacks' family story? I want to learn more about how to get started on a project like this.

Skloot Simulator (for published text) with Paul Allison's edits:

Certainly, let’s delve into the concept of braiding different narratives, a technique pivotal to “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks.” I came to the book with a fixation on structure, understanding that it can make or break the storytelling. Braiding requires introducing all strands early on so readers are prepared when you later switch between them. This crafting ensures that when one narrative strand takes prominence, the reader feels its connection to the others. For your project on AI in education, you would start by delineating your personal journey with AI, integrate the evolving responses of teachers and students, and then describe what AI can do in an educational setting. Each narrative should touch the others at points, allowing the reader to see their interconnectedness.

Remember, like Checkov’s gun, introduce early whatever you plan to leverage later in the narrative. For instance, in the structured braid of my book, the narrative of me and Deborah is chronological and serves as an anchor for jumping between historical context and the family story. Each thread complements the others and provides depth. In your case, your narrative would humanize the topic of AI, teacher and student responses would offer real-world implications, and the AI description would provide the necessary technical background.

Now, thinking about starting such a project: chart the individual strands you want to weave together, understand how they interact, and plan the structure meticulously. Use visual aids like index cards to plot the interactions over time. How you introduce each element sets the stage, so consider it carefully. What might be the most engaging entry point? How will you sustain reader interest through the braids?

Would you like to know more about plotting these strands, the subtleties of transitioning between them, or how to maintain a coherent voice throughout? Or perhaps there’s another direction you’d like to explore?

Please Note: Everything in this comment is AI-generated. It is made up to sound like me.

For a deeper dive into my approach and the technique of braiding narratives, I invite you to read and comment on the conversation I had with David Dobbs. Discover “How Rebecca Skloot Built The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks” here: https://nowcomment.com/documents/361367

DMU Timestamp: November 17, 2023 02:49





Image
0 comments, 0 areas
add area
add comment
change display
Video
add comment

Quickstart: Commenting and Sharing

How to Comment
  • Click icons on the left to see existing comments.
  • Desktop/Laptop: double-click any text, highlight a section of an image, or add a comment while a video is playing to start a new conversation.
    Tablet/Phone: single click then click on the "Start One" link (look right or below).
  • Click "Reply" on a comment to join the conversation.
How to Share Documents
  1. "Upload" a new document.
  2. "Invite" others to it.

Logging in, please wait... Blue_on_grey_spinner