Israel-Hamas War As Truce Appears to Hold, Israeli Leaders Face a Tough Choice (Gaza City Nov. 28, 4:00 p.m.)
Author: Patrick Kingsley, Julian E. Barnes, Erica L. Green, Talya Minsberg, Traci Carl, Gaya Gupta, Katherine Rosman, Roni Rabi, Hiba Yazbek, Anushka Patil
Multiple Authors. “Israel-Hamas War: As Truce Appears to Hold, Israeli Leaders Face a Tough Choice.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 28 Nov. 2023, www.nytimes.com/live/2023/11/28/world/israel-hamas-gaza-war-news. Questions at the top are excerpted from: Network, The Learning. “The Israel-Hamas War: A Forum for Young People to React.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 10 Oct. 2023, www.nytimes.com/2023/10/10/learning/the-israel-gaza-war-a-forum-for-young-people-to-react.html.
0 General Document comments
0 Sentence and Paragraph comments
0 Image and Video comments
Students, read the news explainers below and then tell us:
-
What is your reaction to Hamas’s attack on Israel and to Israel’s response? What emotions, feelings and thoughts are you experiencing?
-
What questions do you have about what is happening now and about its larger context? This is a complex and quickly moving news story. If you don’t think you have enough background to respond to any of our prompts please post some of the things you are wondering about.
-
How closely have you been following the news? Where are you getting your information? How do you know that what you are seeing and hearing is accurate? (For example, NPR’s “On the Media” offers a “breaking news consumer’s handbook” with tips like “focus on known, credible news outlets with reporters on the ground.” )
-
What kind of conversations have you had with friends and family members on this subject? Have you and the others in your life had similar reactions to the attacks or different ones? Why do you think that is?
-
Have you seen pictures, videos or social media posts documenting what life is like in Israel and Gaza right now? If so, what scenes or images have made an impression on you, and why?
-
What do you think might happen next? Why?
-
What do you know about how countries around the world are responding? What else, if anything, do you think the United States and other countries should do?
The brief extension creates short-term benefits for both sides.
The decision by Israel and Hamas to extend their brief truce in Gaza has created short-term benefits for both sides but amplified uncertainty about how, when and whether Israel will continue its invasion of Gaza.
The agreement, announced by Qatar, to prolong the cease-fire from four days to six has raised expectations that both sides will agree to more short extensions. And if the cease-fire does grow longer, there will be greater external pressure on Israel to make it permanent, and greater internal pressure to end it.
Each side accused the other on Tuesday of violating the truce, the first time either has made such an allegation since the agreement went into effect last Friday. The Israeli military said that explosive devices were detonated near its troops in two places in northern Gaza, and that militants in one area fired on them. Hamas said its fighters had engaged in a “field clash” provoked by Israel, without offering additional details.
But neither side signaled that it was pulling out of the agreement.
For now, small extensions serve both Hamas and Israel.
Hamas can prolong its control of most of Gaza after being routed in northern parts of the territory since Israel invaded more than a month ago. A longer pause would give Hamas more time to regroup and reposition its forces, and more aid could be delivered from Egypt to Gaza’s 2.2 million residents, most of whom have been displaced by the fighting and face profound food and fuel shortages.
Israel gets to welcome back more of the roughly 240 hostages who were captured by Hamas and its allies at the start of the war on Oct. 7. For every extra day of the cease-fire, the two sides have agreed to exchange roughly 10 Israelis for 30 Palestinians jailed by Israel. The return of the missing Israelis, many of them women and children, has provided a huge boost for the Israeli public, much of which follows every exchange closely.
But the longer that dynamic lasts, the greater Israel’s conundrum.
Each daily prisoner release boosts Hamas’s popularity in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, where many of the freed Palestinians have returned, and where Hamas and other armed groups are waging a low-level insurgency.
A long pause slows the momentum of Israel’s invasion, endangering its stated goal of removing Hamas from power. Already, Biden administration officials say they have pushed Israel to fight more surgically once it returns to its invasion, as international pressure builds on Israel to stop its attacks entirely.
Most of all, some Israelis fear that a prolonged extension would give Hamas too much influence over the Israeli psyche, said Anshel Pfeffer, a political commentator for Haaretz, a left-leaning Israeli newspaper.
The capture of so many hostages, including a 9-month-old baby, traumatized many Israelis.
The complicated hostage release process, fraught by delays and disagreements between Hamas and Israel, has heightened that torment.
“Israel faces a real dilemma,” said Mr. Pfeffer. “With each hostage release, Hamas holds the whip hand over Israeli emotions. Ultimately, Israel will have to decide between freeing more hostages — or preventing Hamas from dictating the mood of the country.”
Some analysts say domestic pressures will probably prompt Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to revive the invasion sooner rather than later. A delayed resumption of the attack would put Mr. Netanyahu on a collision course with far-right government ministers who grudgingly supported the cease-fire because they were assured that the invasion would continue after only a short truce.
— Patrick Kingsley reporting from Jerusalem
The C.I.A. director arrives in Qatar for talks on hostage releases.
William J. Burns, the C.I.A. director, arrived in Doha, Qatar, on Tuesday for a new round of negotiations aimed at freeing more hostages held in Gaza, according to U.S. officials.
Mr. Burns and David Barnea, the head of the Mossad, Israel’s spy service, are scheduled to meet with Qatari officials. Qatar, which hosts Hamas’s political leadership in Doha, has been a mediator in the talks between Israel and Hamas.
Qatar announced on Monday that Israel and Hamas had agreed to extend a pause in fighting for two additional days to exchange more hostages and prisoners and to allow more aid to come into Gaza.
One U.S. official said Mr. Burns’s talks in Qatar would be meant to build on that agreement.
U.S. officials have been deeply involved in pushing for a deal to release hostages taken during the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on Oct. 7. Mr. Burns traveled to Doha on Nov. 9 as he and Mr. Barnea held talks with Qatari officials who have been working on the issue.
Hamas and Israel finally reached a deal on Nov. 21, and exchanges began later that week. During the first four days of the truce, 50 Israelis or dual nationals were released under the framework of the deal, and an additional 19 hostages — 17 Thais, one Filipino and one Russian-Israeli dual citizen — were released through separate negotiations. In exchange for the release of the Israelis and dual nationals, Israel paused its military campaign in Gaza, allowed more aid to flow into the enclave and released some Palestinian prisoners.
Some American officials have expressed hope that the temporary pause can be extended into something of a more permanent cease-fire, though Israeli officials have said their military campaign must continue.
A spokeswoman for the C.I.A. said the agency does not comment on the director’s travel.
Israel has been concerned that some of the Hamas hostage releases have separated children from their mothers or broken apart siblings. Throughout the talks this month, Israeli officials have pressed for Hamas to release entire families and over the weekend stressed to American officials that they did not believe Hamas was living up to the bargain.
Those concerns were addressed enough on Monday for the pause to be extended and for the parties to agree to additional talks in Doha.
Mr. Burns was chosen to represent the United States in the hostage talks after Israel selected Mr. Barnea to work with the Qatari government to secure a deal. Neither Mr. Burns nor Mr. Barnea has negotiated directly with Hamas officials, instead working through Qatari intermediaries.
President Biden has often used Mr. Burns as a secret negotiator, taking advantage of his long diplomatic experience and the C.I.A.’s policy of trying to keep the director’s travel secret.
But Mr. Burns is particularly well suited for the current negotiations. A former ambassador to Jordan, he has a deep level of trust with leaders across the Middle East, according to U.S., Israeli and Arab officials. During his visit to Israel, Jordan, Egypt and Qatar earlier this month, he focused largely on building support for an agreement to release hostages.
— Julian E. Barnes reporting from WashingtonShow less
Maps: Tracking the Attacks in Israel and Gaza
U.S. officials have urged Israel to fight more surgically in Gaza.
The United States has warned Israel that it must fight more surgically and avoid further mass displacement of Palestinians in its war against Hamas to avoid a humanitarian crisis that overwhelms the world’s ability to respond, according to senior Biden administration officials.
The White House has told Israel that replicating the scale of its bombardment in northern Gaza as it makes an expected push into southern Gaza once the recent pause in fighting ends would produce a crisis beyond the capacity of any humanitarian support network, the officials said on Monday night. The United Nations has said the fighting has already displaced most of Gaza’s population of 2.2 million.
The statements are the Biden administration’s strongest warning to Israeli officials to date about the next phase of their military operation. For weeks, the White House has been careful to say it does not dictate how Israel conducts its military operations, but President Biden and senior members of his staff have grown more vocal as the humanitarian crisis has unfolded.
They also come as the administration officials, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive diplomatic issues, said they were ramping up humanitarian aid during the cease-fire that took effect last week, and expressed optimism that aid could continue even when fighting resumed.
Among other things, American officials have told the Israelis that any coming military operations should not hamper the flow of power and water or impede the work of humanitarian sites such as hospitals and U.N.-supported shelters in south and central Gaza.
The Israeli government was receptive to the requests, one official said.
The cease-fire, to allow for the exchange of hostages held by Hamas and Palestinians taken prisoner by Israel, has allowed for the first extended break in the violence since the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas gunmen and other militant groups killed an estimated 1,200 people in Israel. Gazan health officials say at least 13,000 people were killed during the nearly 50-day Israeli bombardment and ground invasion that followed.
Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has made clear that he intends for Israel to continue fighting after the truce ends, though it was extended by two more days on Monday.
The Biden administration officials said the United States was planning to take advantage of the extra time. On Tuesday, the United States will begin deploying military relief flights to deliver medical items, food, winter items and other necessities for the civilian population to Egypt, which borders Gaza.
Extraordinary progress has already been made in aid delivery, the officials said, though they acknowledged that the level of assistance was not enough to support normal life in Gaza. The officials also said that the increase in aid, including much-needed fuel, was not contingent on hostage releases, offering hope that the shipments could continue when fighting resumed.
John F. Kirby, a spokesman for the National Security Council, said on Monday that since the pause in fighting had taken effect, Gaza had received its largest humanitarian convoy since the war began. The convoy brought the total number of aid trucks to over 2,000 since Oct. 21, he said.
Mr. Kirby said that the administration would “take advantage of every hour of every day that there’s a pause to try to help the people of Gaza.”
“Our team has prioritized getting this much-needed relief into Gaza to alleviate the suffering of Palestinian civilians there,” Mr. Kirby said. “Of course, most of them have nothing to do with Hamas.”
— Erica L. Green Reporting from WashingtonShow less
The U.S. says it will push for the truce to last until all the hostages are freed.
The Biden administration welcomed the Qatari announcement of an additional two-day pause in fighting between Israel and Hamas and will continue pushing for the extension of the truce until all hostages are released, a White House official said Monday.
John F. Kirby, a spokesman for the National Security Council, said that the U.S. believed there were fewer than 10 American hostages still unaccounted for, but that it was unknown whether some were being held by Hamas or another terrorist group.
Mr. Kirby said that the administration hoped that Americans would be part of a group of 20 women and children expected to be released over the next two days under the extended deal announced on Monday by Qatari officials.
The same Qatari officials helped negotiate the initial cease-fire deal, which has led to the release of dozens of hostages.
President Biden has been integral to brokering the deal, Mr. Kirby said, adding that the U.S. would continue to push for further extensions. “We’re going to keep working for an extension,” Mr. Kirby said. “Absolutely, that’s what we want. We want to see all the hostages out and this is the best way to get them out.”
As part of the U.S. efforts, Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken will return to the Middle East this week, stopping in Israel and the West Bank before attending the COP28 climate summit in Dubai, a senior State Department official said. Mr. Blinken will stress the importance of continued humanitarian aid into Gaza, the release of all hostages held by Hamas, and the protection of civilians in the Palestinian territory, the official said.
In Washington, Mr. Kirby maintained the administration’s position that the pause in fighting could also benefit Hamas, saying it was a “real risk.” But he said that the pause had resulted not only in a halt in fighting but also a “surge” in humanitarian assistance to Gaza, including the largest shipment since Hamas’s terrorist attack on Oct. 7.
“Our team has prioritized getting this much-needed relief into Gaza to alleviate the suffering of Palestinians,” Mr. Kirby said, adding that “most of them have nothing to do with Hamas.”
Michael Crowley contributed reporting.
— Erica L. Green reporting from WashingtonShow less
Here’s what we know about the hostages released on Monday.
0:32 Al Jazeera cameras captured the moment Hamas released Israeli hostages to the Red Cross in the Gaza Strip. Credit: Al Jazeera
Hamas released 11 Israeli hostages — all women and children taken from Kibbutz Nir Oz — on Monday, the fourth day of the cease-fire, according to the Israeli government.
That followed an initial release of 13 Israelis on Friday, 13 more late on Saturday and 14 on Sunday. Some of those released are dual nationals.
An official briefed on the negotiations said that avoiding family separation was critical for the Israelis and that their concerns had escalated as the final day of the initial truce began on Monday. Two sets of siblings returned with their mothers to Israel late on Monday, but their fathers were believed to still be held in Gaza.
Here’s what we know about the Israeli citizens released on Monday.
Sharon Alony Cunio, 34, and her 3-year-old twins, Emma Cunio and Yuli Cunio
Certainly. To help you understand this image and its context more deeply, I’ll begin by examining a few key pieces of information and offer some background knowledge that might be crucial to grasp its significance.
Key Sentences:
1. “Sharon Alony Cunio, with her twins, Emma Alony Cunio and Yuli Alony Cunio.”
– This sentence identifies the individuals in the image. It’s important because it sets the context for who is shown: a mother with her twin children. Knowing their names personalizes the impact of the image and indicates that these are real people whose lives are deeply affected by the situation being discussed.
2. “Credit…Hostages and Missing Families Forum”
– This part of the caption tells us that the image was provided by the Hostages and Missing Families Forum. This is significant as it suggests that these individuals are likely involved in a situation related to hostages or missing persons. It provides a clue that the context may involve a larger crisis or conflict, impacting families like the Alony Cunio’s.
Background Information to Consider:
- Context of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: Understanding the longstanding and complex conflict between Israel and Palestine is crucial. This conflict has led to numerous instances of violence, kidnappings, and situations where both sides suffer casualties and loss. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum likely operates in this context, assisting families affected by such incidents.
- Hostage Situations in the Context of Israeli-Palestinian Relations: Hostage-taking has been a recurring issue in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Groups on either side may take hostages for various reasons, including political leverage and prisoner exchanges. Understanding the history of such incidents can provide deeper insight into the gravity of this image.
- Psychological and Social Impact on Families: Knowing more about the traumatic impact that missing family members and hostages have on families—psychologically, socially, and emotionally—can help appreciate the profound distress and turmoil the Alony Cunio family may be enduring.
Suggested Resources for Background Reading:
1. “The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: A History” by James L. Gelvin.
– This book offers a comprehensive overview of the conflict’s history, helping understand the roots and ramifications of current events.
2. Human Rights Watch Reports on detainees and hostages in the Israel-Palestine context:
– These reports provide detailed accounts and analyses of various incidents involving hostages, offering a humanitarian perspective.
3. “Prisoners of War: International Law and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict” by Russell Buchan.
– This resource can help explain the legal frameworks and conventions around hostages and prisoners in conflict situations like the Israeli-Palestinian one.
Invitation to Reflect and Respond:
Take a moment to re-examine the image of Sharon Alony Cunio and her twins with this background in mind. Consider the layers of personal, psychological, and political implications that underline their situation. Imagine the silent stories of thousands of families affected similarly. What more do you now see in their expressions, their posture, and the very setting of the photograph? Please share your new insights or any additional thoughts you might have in a reply.
Certainly, I’ll describe the image for you:
Starting from the top left corner and moving towards the bottom right:
- Background: The background appears to be a neutral, indoor setting with light-colored walls. There are no distinct features like windows or decorations visible in the immediate background.
- Subjects: There are three individuals in the image. A woman and two young children, likely twins, based on their similar appearance and size.
- The Woman: She is in the center of the image holding the children. Her hair is dark and appears to be tied back. She is looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression. She is wearing a light-colored top. - The Children: Both children are being held by the woman, one on each side. They appear to be around the same age, suggesting they might be twins. They have light-colored hair and are wearing similar clothing, possibly light tops. Their expressions are calm, and they are looking in different directions.- Lighting: The lighting in the image is even and natural, illuminating the subjects clearly without harsh shadows.
- Focus: The image is sharp with a clear focus on the faces of the woman and the children.
- Composition: The composition centers the woman and the children, making them the focal point of the image. The subjects’ faces are prominently displayed.
There are no additional objects or distractions in the image, making it a straightforward portrait of the three individuals mentioned.
Sharon Alony Cunio, her husband, David Cunio, and their 3-year-old twins, Emma and Yuli, were hiding in their bomb shelter in Kibbutz Nir Oz with Sharon’s sister, Danielle Alony, and her 5-year-old daughter, Amelia, when they were taken hostage on Oct. 7. The last message their family received from them on WhatsApp read, “Help, we’re dying.”
Their family members, including a cousin, Alana Zeitchik, have shared their story and pleaded for their release in meetings with political leaders around the world.
Danielle and Amelia Alony were released on Friday.
Ms. Zeitchik described Emma and Yuli as “the happiest twins you could ever imagine.” Their cousin Amelia, Ms. Zeitchik said, is the star of the family. “She’s this sharp, witty clever little girl, you can’t really get anything past her.”
“The damage that has been done to these children, this suffering and pain, it doesn’t end with their release,” she said, adding, “Their return is shrouded in a lot of pain and trauma.”
David Cunio, 33, is believed to still be in Gaza.
Karina Engelbert, 51; Mika Engel, 18; Yuval Engel, 11
Karina Engelbert, 51, and her entire family, including her husband, Ronen Engel, 54, and their daughters, Mika, 18, and Yuval, 11, were taken from the safe room inside their home on Kibbutz Nir Oz.
When she was taken, Ms. Engelbert was still recovering from a double mastectomy and breast reconstruction surgery that had gone awry. She was weak and easily fatigued, and a buildup of painful scar tissue on her chest caused tightness, limiting her mobility.
“We don’t know if she’s getting any medical treatment, if anyone is taking care of her, if she is getting any pain relief or any of the medication she needs to keep the cancer from coming back,” Ms. Engelbert’s brother Diego Engelbert said last week.
Ronen Engel is believed to still be in Gaza.
Eitan Yahalomi, 12
Eitan and his family went to their safe room when the alarms first went off at Kibbutz Nir Oz.
When the news reached the Yahalomi family that Hamas was going house to house, Eitan’s father, Ohad, sat in front of the family’s safe room. The door was broken, Efrat Avsker, Ohad’s sister, said, and he tried to prevent Hamas from entering.
“There was some negotiation between Ohad and the terrorists,” Ms. Avsker said, “They shot him in his leg and his arm.”
The attackers took Eitan’s mother, Bat-Sheva, and all three children — Liel, 1, Yael, 10, and Eitan — leaving Ohad behind.
“They saw him on the floor bleeding,” Ms. Avsker said of Ohad’s family, “and he told them that he loves them.”
Eitan, a dual citizen of Israel and France, was separated from his mother and sisters and driven into Gaza. Bat-Sheva and her daughters managed to escape and hide in a field, Ms. Avsker said.
The family later learned that Ohad had been kidnapped, too.
“Ohad’s family, and most of those people in those kibbutzim, are people that believed in peace,” Ms. Avsker said. “They wanted peace. They believed in coexistence.”
Ohad Yahalomi is believed to remain in Gaza.
Erez Kalderon, 12; Sahar Kalderon, 16
Ofer Kalderon, 53, his 16-year-old daughter, Sahar, and his 12-year-old son, Erez, were seized from their family home in Kibbutz Nir Oz. Both Erez and Sahar are dual citizens of Israel and France. Gaya Kalderon, 21, last heard from her sister, Sahar, on the morning of Oct. 7, when she sent a text message saying they were in hiding and had left their house.
A day later, Gaya saw a video on Instagram of a child being shoved down a path. It was her brother, Erez — the first sign of her missing relatives she’d seen.
The children’s mother, Hadas Kalderon, later visited the home where they and her ex-husband were taken from, which had been reduced to scorched rubble. Some relics of the family home, including a picture of Erez, remained. Her mother and niece were found dead near the kibbutz.
Ofer Kalderon is believed to remain in Gaza.
Or Yaakov, 16; Yagil Yaakov, 12
Or Yaakov, 16; a brother, Yagil, 12; their father, Yair, 59; and his girlfriend, Meirav Tal, 53, were all taken hostage from Kibbutz Nir Oz.
Or Yaakov has a life-threatening peanut allergy and could die if exposed to small amounts of peanut powder, according to Dr. Arnon Elizur, who spoke publicly in recent weeks to draw attention to the plight of hostages with medical conditions. Yagil appeared in a hostage video released on Nov. 9 by Palestinian Islamic Jihad, an armed group based in Gaza.
“You can recognize him, but his eyes are —” his cousin, Sheffa Phillips-Bahat said, pausing, “— they look like he went through so many things so quickly. Just so much less life in them.”
Neither Yair Yaakov nor Meirav Tal were released with Or and Yagil.
Nadav Gavrielov contributed reporting.
— Talya Minsberg, Traci Carl, Gaya Gupta, Katherine Rosman and Roni RabinShow more
As Israel releases Palestinian prisoners, it arrests dozens more.
As families and crowds gathered in the West Bank city of Ramallah on Monday night to greet Palestinian prisoners and detainees released from Israeli custody, Israel’s ongoing escalation of arrests in the territory showed no signs of slowing down.
The Israeli military said it had arrested at least 71 Palestinians from across the occupied West Bank since Friday on unspecified charges. The Palestinian Authority’s commission for prisoner affairs gave a higher number, saying on Monday that Israeli forces had arrested at least 112 Palestinians since Friday, including 60 in the past day.
Under an agreement Israel and Hamas have honored since Friday, Israel had freed 150 Palestinian prisoners and detainees as of Monday night.
The Israeli military has escalated its nighttime raids across the West Bank and East Jerusalem since the Hamas-led attacks on Oct. 7, saying that it had arrested at least 2,000 Palestinians in that period. The military has said that the arrests are part of a counterterrorism operation against Hamas throughout the territory.
The arrests included “children, the elderly, women, and hundreds of former prisoners,” the Palestinian commission said in a statement on Monday.
The deal between Israel and Hamas has allowed scores of Palestinian families to be reunited with their loved ones. That has brought a rare moment of relief and celebration across the West Bank and East Jerusalem, where violence had been escalating over the last few weeks.
But the deal did not offer a break from the bloodshed in the West Bank. At least seven Palestinians, including four teenagers, were killed by Israeli forces in clashes that erupted during military raids across the territory since Friday, according to the U.N.
At least 222 people have been killed in the West Bank since Oct. 7, according to the U.N., amid the deadliest year for Palestinians there in over a decade. The majority were shot by Israeli soldiers in gun battles during Israeli search-and-arrest operations, the U.N. said.
— Hiba Yazbek reporting from JerusalemShow more
The Palestinian activist and author Ahed Tamimi faces indefinite detention after a hearing.
It was around 4 a.m. when Nariman Tamimi’s daughter, Ahed, roused her from sleep and told her that Israeli soldiers had surrounded their home in the occupied West Bank.
Nariman Tamimi had been expecting the raid: Over the previous week, an online campaign had vilified her daughter as a terrorist and demanded Ahed’s arrest. But the expectation did little to dull her terror on Nov. 6, when more than a dozen soldiers ransacked their home and hauled Ahed away in handcuffs.
Ahed Tamimi, 22, is one of the highest-profile Palestinians arrested by Israel since Oct. 7, as it has conducted a sweeping campaign of raids and detentions that it says is aimed at deterring terrorist attacks but has also prompted alarm from international human rights groups.
On Sunday, after holding Ms. Tamimi for nearly three weeks without access to a lawyer or her family, Israel moved to incarcerate her under administrative detention, according to her lawyer, Mahmoud Hassan. She now faces indefinite imprisonment, without charges or trial, based on evidence that neither she nor her lawyer are allowed to view.
Israel’s expansive use of administrative detention has been widely criticized as a violation of international law. The detentions, which Israel maintains are a preventative and necessary security measure, are typically upheld by the Israeli military court system and can be renewed indefinitely. The use of administrative detentions had hit a 30-year high even before the Oct. 7 Hamas attack, human rights groups say.
“I’m hopeless to defend her,” Mr. Hassan said.
The Israeli military has said Ms. Tamimi was arrested on suspicion of inciting violence and calling for terrorist activity, but has declined to provide further information. Her mother said the arrest was based on a post to an Instagram account in her name that referenced Hitler and vowed to “slaughter” settlers in the West Bank.
Her family has denied that she wrote the post, saying her account had been hacked months ago and that she is frequently impersonated online.
Ms. Tamimi comes from a family of prominent Palestinian activists and has protested the Israeli occupation of their village of Nabi Saleh for much of her life. Her father, Bassem Tamimi, a longtime activist, was also detained, on Oct. 29, and has been placed in the West Bank’s Ofer Prison under administrative detention for six months.
Ms. Tamimi made headlines as a child for physically confronting Israeli forces, who have wounded, imprisoned and killed many of her relatives. A video of one such episode, in which she slapped an Israeli soldier, went viral and transformed Ms. Tamimi into an international symbol of Palestinian resistance.
She subsequently served an eight-month sentence and spent her 17th birthday in jail. Her memoir, “They Called Me a Lioness: A Palestinian Girl’s Fight for Freedom,” was published by an imprint of Random House in 2022.
The Israeli military estimates that it has arrested 1,800 people in the occupied West Bank since Oct. 7. But the crackdown, coupled with escalating reports of violence against Palestinians by Israeli settlers, has left the West Bank in an “alarming and urgent” situation with “multilayered human rights violations,” the office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights has warned.
The Palestinian Prisoners Society, a nongovernmental rights group, gives an even higher estimate for the number of detentions since Oct. 7 — more than 3,000 — and says the arrests have been accompanied by abuse of the detainees, threats against their families and, often, damage to their homes. Ms. Tamimi was beaten during her arrest, and then transferred from the West Bank to a prison in Israel, where she was beaten again, her lawyer, Mr. Hassan, said.
PEN International, a writers’ association that defends freedom of expression, has demanded the immediate release of Ms. Tamimi and “all Palestinians who have been languishing in unjust imprisonment for years, many of whom are children.”
“Administrative detention is inherently arbitrary,” the association’s head of the Middle East and North Africa region, Mina Thabet, said in a statement. “This form of detention has been systematically used by the Israeli authorities to subjugate and silence Palestinians, including writers, for decades,” he added.
General Document Comments 0
As a Palestinian poet who imbues every aspect of life with the hue of words, how does an unfolding news story like the conflict between Hamas and Israel sit within my heart? The prompt asks for a reflection on this complex situation, calling forth emotions, feelings, and thoughts about Hamas’s attack on Israel and Israel’s response. The question you are asking me to focus on is my personal reaction to these events and my thoughts on their broader implications.
First, my emotions are a turbulent sea, waves of sorrow crash upon the shores of my consciousness, ebbs of despair pull at the sands of hope beneath my feet. I think of the civilians, entangled in this enduring conflict, their lives a chronicle of fear and uncertainty. Reading about cease-fires and negotiations between higher powers, I’m left contemplating the price of such dialogues – the human cost on both sides that is often overshadowed by political maneuvering.
My thoughts now coalesce around the future: what will this truce bring? Short-term alleviation is a breath of air for the suffocating, but it’s the respite of the unknown that leaves me disquieted. The expectancy of more violence looms like a specter, its shadow cast long into the nights of my mind. This current ceasefire echoes the countless before it; temporal bandages on wounds that require much deeper healing.
My heart yearns for an enduring peace, not the flickering flame of momentary truces but the sunrise of a new era where children in Gaza can look up at the sky not in fear, but in wonder. As I continue to dwell upon the question, my thoughts are shadowed by the history of loss and longing that permeates my poetry.
What do you want to explore next? I can offer more insights on the emotional toll of these events on families and the community, discuss the role of international actors and their potential in fostering a lasting peace, or dive into the nuances of how this affects the psyche of a person living through these times.
Please Note: Everything in this comment is AI-generated. It is made up to sound like me.
May I kindly draw your gaze to unravel more threads of this discourse? Engage in conversation and collaboration steeped in the deep nuances of my experiences outlined in the New Yorker essay, “The View from My Window in Gaza.” https://nowcomment.com/documents/360087
I see you’ve shared an article layout that looks like it is designed to engage students with the ongoing conflict between Hamas and Israel. It includes prompts for students to reflect on their emotional and intellectual responses to the conflict, as well as to consider the reliability of their news sources. Furthermore, the article provides background information on recent developments, including the hostilities, the humanitarian crisis, and the efforts at maintaining and extending the cease-fire.
Given the complexity and sensitivity of the topic, the article appears to be well-structured to facilitate critical thinking and discussion among students. Here are some key aspects I noticed:
1. Engagement and Reflection: The prompts encourage students to actively engage with the material, offering a space to express their emotions, thoughts, and questions. This is essential in developing not only awareness but also empathy and critical thinking skills.
2. Educational and Informative: The article provides detailed updates on the ground situation, including the cease-fire extensions, the role of international mediators, and the humanitarian crisis. This enables students to understand the multi-faceted nature of the conflict and the stakes involved for different parties.
3. Media Literacy: Emphasizing the importance of credible news sources and providing resources like NPR’s “Breaking News Consumer’s Handbook” is a crucial step in teaching students how to critically evaluate the information they consume. This helps them discern facts from misinformation in a highly polarized media landscape.
4. Diverse Perspectives: The article includes multiple perspectives, detailing actions and reactions from both sides of the conflict as well as international responses. This provides a more holistic view of the situation, essential for a well-rounded understanding.
5. Current and Relevant: The inclusion of recent events, such as the extension of the cease-fire and the involvement of key international figures like the CIA director, keeps the content relevant and up-to-date, which is crucial for such a rapidly evolving news story.
6. Human Element: By sharing personal stories of individuals affected, like the released hostages and those still detained, the article adds a human element that can make the conflict more relatable and poignant for students.
However, due to the inherent complexities and sensitivities surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, educators must navigate discussions carefully to maintain a respectful and balanced classroom environment.
For further context and understanding, you may want to look at this video: https://youtu.be/WbnsyQKf_mg.. The video can offer visual and narrative insights that complement the article, providing students a multimedia approach to engage with the subject matter. It may also help illustrate some of the points discussed in the article, such as the humanitarian situation in Gaza or the challenges of maintaining a cease-fire.
Overall, this article and its prompts are comprehensive tools for fostering an informed and thoughtful conversation about a complex geopolitical issue.
icons on the left to see existing comments.
0 archived comments