NowComment
2-Pane Combined
Comments:
Full Summaries Sorted

Documentary Film April 8


0 General Document comments
0 Sentence and Paragraph comments
0 Image and Video comments


Documentary Film April 8

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 1 0
No paragraph-level conversations. Start one.
New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 1, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

The Jennings war films never explain, exhort, harangue. They observe.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 2 0
profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:10PM) : Give some examples of the film's power to observe.
profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:13PM) : As "reality / "documentary" type films, the Jennning war films were looking to display the perspectives of the people rather than explicitly placing the political propaganda of political leaders. Throughout the film we observe the people's everyday tasks more

as contribution to the war. Whether that includes administrative tasks or taking larger roles such as active fighting.

profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:11AM) : Although part of the propaganda is that everyone has to do his or her part.
profile_photo
Apr 26
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 26 2016 6:21PM) : Right-- I feel that the power of "documentary" type films lies in its strength to use fairly objective / "observation" scenes that provoke messages that can be interpreted as "propaganda."
profile_photo
Apr 27
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 27 2016 7:47AM) : Yes, observing can be a form of commentary.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:27AM) : But more

But not always as reliable as the commentary from the people who it actually affected.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 1:56PM) : The power of documentary films more

I think that the power of documentary films gives messages objectively. Unlike the commercial fictional feature or the non-commercial sponsored documentary, Jennings’ war films showed objective scenes rather than explaining each scene. Observing the British’s everyday tasks during the wartime without any commentary may help audience focus on the film objectively.

profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:12PM) : That is a good point.
profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 1:32PM) : Power to observe [Edited] more

Having not been alive during the 1940’s makes it more difficult to determine how normal and real these shots and scenes were. However I still feel a strong sense of realism to this film, like what we are watching is how life was in the 1940’s. You don’t get the sense that these are actors trying to perfect their lines and scenes, instead they’re just normal civilians going about their normal lives, which is what they were supposed to represent. From the very soft and happy start to the film to the gradual shift to a more serious plot, Jennings doesn’t put together scenes to excite and entice his viewers, rather he portrays something that can almost be interpreted as truth.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:10AM) : Reading the history of the period would help to evaluate the film's realism.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:28AM) : Not always more

Getting historical context is one thing, but actually living through it is another.

profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 2:52PM) : I don't think living through something better equips you with what happened. more

There are many situations that occur around us and we have no clue what’s really going on. With documentaries, they present to us what we are to believe are the facts and we ourselves then determine whether it happened this way or not.

profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 1:37PM) : observe [Edited] more

I think it is the fact that this film tried to stay as objective as possible, without giving its opinion or something. For instance: when one man is asking the other what he used to do for work before the war and the guy is saying ‘writing, advertising and stuff’. They have different accents (the guy who asked the question probably never could do something in advertising). It shows that these two men did only meet because of the Second World War. Different people from different backgrounds came together because they wanted to do their part. It doesn’t say ‘look how different these guys are’ or they don’t judge each other for something, bit I think the viewer knows. I think that makes a documentary more objective and may help the audience to observe the film in a more objective way.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 10:33AM) : observe more

I think the power of documentary films is that they reveal audiences to real-life scenarios. The Jennings war film inspires a new understanding of viewer’s world and showed the impact of each scene rather than explaining them.

profile_photo
May 20
Colon Greene Colon Greene (May 20 2016 3:51PM) : The Jenning's war films give off an extreme amount of realism and objective thinking.
profile_photo
May 20
Colon Greene Colon Greene (May 20 2016 4:01PM) : The individualism of the film only works with the back drop of war giving everyone clear cut signs as to where their roles were to take place. more

The individualism of the film only works with the back drop of war giving everyone clear cut signs as to where their roles were to take place. The men are soldiers, leaders in a foreign land,while the women ventured outside of the home and began to work in factories and textile plants. The war allowed for people to breakout of their everyday models an become people they did not know they were.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 2, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 2, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

Fires Were Started by Humphrey Jennings is quite hard to decipher at first. Looking deeper into the film however, and judging them by their actions, as opposed to dialogue, we see that it is about heroism.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 3 0
profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:10PM) : Describe the nature of the heroism.
profile_photo
Apr 14
Wilde Diaz Wilde Diaz (Apr 14 2016 11:36AM) : Heroism more

It is not an easy task whether it be for theatrical purposes or in the case Jennings tries to portray, the reality of the British firefighters that had to fight fires while defending their own lives from the bombs being dropped. The fact that these individuals had to go out and put out fires is an act of courage as is, but with the added element of the bombs, their perseverance to do what had to be done for home and country is even further elevated. Jennings recognizes this and seeks to capture and portray it in her film.

profile_photo
Apr 15
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 15 2016 7:32AM) : And they did it in a matter of fact way. [Edited]
profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:17PM) : The heroism lies in the hands of each individual. The film draws a notion that as long as we take active participation in the war, we can be heroes .This draws back to the idea of individualism-- each action is important. Whether we are male / female more

on an active fighting duty or being a messenger, each individual takes an important role.

profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:12AM) : Right.
profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 2:54PM) : Agree with this. But not everyone will see it this way. more

Being a hero could also be a shoulder to cry on for those in need, regardless of whether or not the person is actively assisting in other ways.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 1:00AM) : Heroism is something that doesn't need to be asked to be done. more

I think heroism is in the sacrifice that people make for the greater good without the need of being asked. The men who went out to put out those fires during WW2 were not doing it because they thought they would be remembered, but because it was a job that needed to be done and it was a way to do their part during the war.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:15AM) : I agree
profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 2:10PM) : Heroism [Edited] more

The film shows the real life firefighters and their hardship the field fighting a major fire. Jennings tries to depict their brotherhood, and the fury of flames, and the sacrifice of these brave men in their duties. In this regard, brotherhood of team members and the dramatic story turn into a heroic display, and thus we can see “heroism” clearly.

profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:13PM) : Heroism as a kind of collective accomplishment.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:30AM) : Maybe more

Heroism usually likes to focus on an individual so I’m not sure if it is the right word here. I’m blanking on the word for heroism but as a nation or people though.

profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 1:50PM) : heroism [Edited] more

I think that Jennings takes an interesting approach to heroism in this film. He first humanizes his characters and portrays them as regular people, ones you wouldn’t think would be heroes. An example of that is when they are all crowding around the piano and singing upbeat songs. Then things shift in the film and you see them doing their jobs but not in a extraordinary fashion. Despite the commonality in their actions, as a whole they are still heroic nevertheless.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:10AM) : He is a master of combining the ordinary and the heroic
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 1:41PM) : Heroism [Edited] more

I think heroism is when you just do something, just because you want to rebuild something or help someone, instead of watching from the sideline and waiting for stuff to happen. They all did their part. For instance before the fighting began, the men are all together next to this piano and singing a song about dying. It’s almost some sort of tradition, this has been going on for years. ’Don’t miss me when I’m gone’ they sing. It some sort of fraternization, some sort of community singing. They knew they could die but they did it anyway, because they felt like it was the right thing to do. For their country, but mostly for their people. For me, that’s true heroism.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 10:48AM) : heroism more

The essence of the heroism is a ruthless dedication to reality and to the accurate necessities of our lives – in the film, people didn’t question about devoting their life to the war just like their singing lyrics shows. At this period, it was what they had to do, and I think that will eventually lead to the heroism.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 3, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.
New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 3, Sentence 2 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

I believe that it is a film that capitalizes on the importance of each individual in a system.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 4 0
profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:11PM) : How does films show the importance of each individual?
profile_photo
Apr 14
Wilde Diaz Wilde Diaz (Apr 14 2016 11:38AM) : Individuality more

When one does mundane tasks such as picking up calls or filling out paperwork, one forgets the importance as to what they play themselves in the overall structure of the organization. From the radar detector personnel, watchers of German aircraft, to the women who would relay messages to the fire stations themselves, everyone played a part. Even when a bomb hit the building of one of these relay women, she dragged herself to her post and continued to do her responsibility. Her actions as an individual show how pivotal her role is in the overall structure of the system she is a part of.

profile_photo
Apr 15
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 15 2016 7:33AM) : Good point. Jennings is showing how everyone has a contribution to make n
profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:21PM) : I agree. Placing an importance on individualism also builds rapport and nationalism for the "British spirit." Given the large and dangerous nature of the war, its easy for one to get lost in the shuffle. Owning and being proud of their role in the war more

gives people self motivation and drive to suceed.

profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:13AM) : Individuals working together serving themselves and others.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 1:02AM) : There was also no arrogance coming from anyone. They all understood that each role was important no matter whether you were putting out a fire or picking up a phone, everyone had an important job.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:16AM) : Right
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:31AM) : Comradery more

Comradery is quite common in times of war

profile_photo
May 20
Ms Kindra Cooper Ms Kindra Cooper (May 20 2016 11:00PM) : I agree that this film focuses on the coordination of individuals during wartime more

I agree. Particularly the scenes that show the women at work during a time when few women had careers. And the administrative tasks and coordination without which the war could not have run smoothly. Each individual is but a cog in a much larger piece of machinery, but indispensable nonetheless.

profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:31AM) : It is more

It is kind of communist in that regard don’t you think?

profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 2:56PM) : I agree with this. It's an action regardless of how little it appears that makes one as important people fighting on the front line, if not more. more

This is an example of continuation. In spite of the war, life moves on even during the worst of times.

profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:42PM) : Another way the film shows importance of each individual is showing the INCLUSION of each individual, supporting the notion that even the smallest action can make a difference.
profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:13AM) : Yes
profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 2:57PM) : I can't agree with this enough.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 2:28PM) : The film shows every role is important. Firefighters face life threatening moments on the dangerous field, and women in the dispatch office fulfill their duties. They are all important in keeping the country safe.
profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:14PM) : That is right. The film suggests that everyone has a vital role to play when a democracy has to go to war.
profile_photo
May 12
Ramiro Thompson Ramiro Thompson (May 12 2016 6:18PM) : I agree more

I agree here I also feel that film did not disproportionately give importance to specific role. In fact it showed how cooperation and working together brings success.

profile_photo
May 13
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 13 2016 8:17AM) : A democratic film.
profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 2:59PM) : Exactly. It's all about teamwork. more

You can’t win a war by yourself, you need all the help you can get and you need to work together in accomplishing the collective goal. By the firefighters and the office workers working together, they helped put out the fires that resulted in oppositions bombing attacks. By their actions they helped save lives while their side helped fight against the Germans.

profile_photo
May 15
Jessica Nieberg Jessica Nieberg (May 15 2016 6:18PM) : Women- [Edited] more

I think the importance of the individual is most seen through the women in this film. The scene in the dispatch office is one that is quite memorable, as the women took calls and then charted where the men were and where they were going. This one responsibility helped the entire work place flow more easily.

profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 1:57PM) : importance of individual more

I think a key point here is the importance of the individual stems from the fact that this a time of war. Without a war a viewer could not really see how important each individual is. Since it is a dangerous time and situation Jennings is able to show how every action by every worker is highly valuable and has a huge impact to completing the overall task . Without war the importance of the individuls’ actions would just be lost.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:11AM) : Perhaps not lost but certainly not as dramatic.
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 1:46PM) : individual [Edited] more

Everybody is doing their part, making their own decisions, playing their role. The men fight, the women fill out paperwork and they all take it extremely serious. You have this close-up of the hands of this woman and they are extremely feminine. They show that it’s no problem to work and still be feminine at the same time. There is also a lot of inter-cutting in the film to show what the men and women are doing for work. They are responsible for their jobs and know they are part of this larger system where everybody plays their role.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 10:57AM) : individual more

For example, despite it was not usual for women to work at this period, in the film, they were doing deskwork. Even when they sensed the imminent danger, they didn’t stop their work – it tells the importance of each individual. Each of them working together to help out others.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 4, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

The film succeeded in projecting the British spirit, a spirit that was stronger than the Nazi air bombers.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 5 0
profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:11PM) : Give some examples of this "British spirit."
profile_photo
Apr 14
Wilde Diaz Wilde Diaz (Apr 14 2016 11:41AM) : The British Spirit more

Men and women risking their lives throughout the film show the endurance of the British Spirit. From the army personnel looking for German invasion and airplanes, to women working in buildings while under bomber siege to the fire fighters risking their lives in the dead of night with the fires they are battling as their source of both warmth and danger show how the British Spirit endures. The way that the Royal British Airforce, despite being outnumbered drastically, still took to the skies to defend their country goes to show that despite the odds the British Spirit endures and Jennings succeeds and capturing that to a degree.

profile_photo
Apr 15
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 15 2016 7:34AM) : To what degree?
profile_photo
Apr 19
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 19 2016 12:01PM) : I think the inclusion of women in the war efforts showed this "British spirit." Personally watching, I felt that there must have been a sense of nationalism depicting women taking a high responsibility in the war. more

It reminded me of America’s own Rosie the Riveter during WWII.

profile_photo
Apr 20
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 20 2016 7:41AM) : Yes, like Rosie the Riverter, and giving women a sense of purpose.
profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:24PM) : It also gives women a sense of unity. Although this film highlights individuality on a micro level (individuals being active and passionate in their roles), it creates a strong unity of nationalism aka "British spirit" on a macro level.
profile_photo
May 12
Ramiro Thompson Ramiro Thompson (May 12 2016 7:10PM) : agree more

True, we see an important here as well

profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 1:05AM) : British Spirit more

When the fire station was bombed and the woman attending the phones went on to give her message is a good example of the British spirit. It shows that they will keep doing their jobs until their dead. As long as there is a chance they can keep going, they will still fight.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:17AM) : they're
profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 2:45PM) : British Spirit more

I think British Spirit is courage. When the sirens and noise of German airplanes are heard loudly. All members of firefighters would be nervous. But they continue to sing, and thus they keep their spirits up, and they are to be brave firefighters to save other citizens from attacks.

profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:14PM) : Almost what you might call unassuming courage.
profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 2:13PM) : British spirit more

The British spirit is the power of how all the workers kept doing their jobs despite being in life threatening situations. From bombs to heavy fires these workers kept on working.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:12AM) : Yes, they are not demoralized but just the opposite.
profile_photo
May 12
Ramiro Thompson Ramiro Thompson (May 12 2016 6:22PM) : Back to the Signing more

Singing can be seen as an example of one’s spirit. After the chaos and hard work we see them signing- this is a way how to uplift your spirit and feel better despite what happened. especially when everyone else is doing it.

profile_photo
May 13
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 13 2016 8:34AM) : Togetherness
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 2:00PM) : British spirit [Edited] more

In this documentary, they sing all the time, they talk with everybody, women and men are equal, people from different backgrounds are treated the same way, you can really see they are all in it together. So it really shows the British spirit, the togetherness during the war of wanting to fight for their country and their people.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 11:08AM) : British spirit more

I think the British spirit is solidarity and community. People at that period tired of continually interrupting their sleep to go back and forth to their work. Women are the good example of this British spirit. In the film, they didn’t stop working even though there was imminent danger to their lives.

profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 3:01PM) : The British forged ahead despite attacks against their livelihood and all that they stood for. [Edited] more

The “British Spirit” is all about togetherness, patriotism and unity. During the time of war they came together and took care of their own. They did this not because they were told to, but because they had to. It’s not in them not to help others.

profile_photo
May 20
Colon Greene Colon Greene (May 20 2016 4:10PM) : The Infallible "British Spirit" more

The infallible “British Spirit” I feel is shown beautifully through women in this film. They are seen as having been patriots for their nation and refused to give up on more than one occasion throughout. They are seen continuously preserving in great oppositions.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 5, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

Propaganda yes, but a great mix of script and reality.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 6 0
profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:13PM) : What is scripted? What is reality? How do both contribute to the film's propagandistic purposes?
profile_photo
Apr 14
Wilde Diaz Wilde Diaz (Apr 14 2016 11:45AM) : Differentiating between scripted and reality more

There is no doubt, what happened to Britain by the Germans did occur. Jenning’s uses a script in order to provide a storyline of events even though this must of been one of many, many stories of the people of Britain. While not ascertaining hers is based on a true story, it is however based on real events. The characters used, such as the fire fighters, were real fire fighters which adds to the validity of the events that transpired. By combining both Jennings is able to create a video that shows the will and endurance of the British, thus remaining a constant reminder to stand the test of history of what the British are capable of under peril.

profile_photo
Apr 15
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 15 2016 7:34AM) : A script also creates the vision of the director.
profile_photo
May 15
Jessica Nieberg Jessica Nieberg (May 15 2016 7:16PM) : Script- more

I think a script also helps portray a single story line. Without it, an audience can easily get confused with conflicting messages.

profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:38PM) : Even though the events did realistically happen, each scene can be edited to be perceived a certain way. A script is just a way to organize that "realistic" content to support a message. For example, scenes of women working in the war actually did happen. more

However, that content can be organized in a way where the main purpose of including those scenes is intentionally “scripted” to draw attention to the strong collective efforts of including EVERYONE in the war.

profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:16AM) : The word is actually, not realistically.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 1:07AM) : Script and Reality more

By blurring the lines of what is scripted and what is reality, it makes the scripted scenes feel much realer. If “this” part is true why can’t “that” part be. This helps the propagandist purposes of the film be more believable.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:17AM) : Yes, that I think is the intention.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:34AM) : Intention more

And intention is what shapes all films even if the director does not know it.

profile_photo
May 20
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (May 20 2016 12:38PM) : Well it can't be intention if the director didn't intend to add something to a film.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 3:06PM) : script and reality more

I think Jennings mixes the genre of scripted drama and documentary films. Jennings uses real firefighters instead of actors to show the roles of “reality.” Producing all scripted dramatic scenes of firehouse describe their real life. The drama with the realism makes the film approach people easily.

profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:15PM) : Why wouldn't it be more real without a script?
profile_photo
May 20
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (May 20 2016 1:23PM) : I also think it could be more real without script. Shooting without script absolutely can show ability to react in the real circumstances.
profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 2:30PM) : script and reality [Edited] more

The script here is that Jennings is still the director and he is in charge of putting the shots and scenes into a film. The arrangement, order, and character placement is still all his. The reality is these were real events that did take place and through his script he is able to portray these occurrences in a very realistic way. Since Jennings is able to masterfully orchestrate the script and reality, in my opinion his propagandistic purposes are achieved at the highest possible rate.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:13AM) : There is a certain order of events, following a day and night in the lives of firemen that provides a structure for the film.
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 2:02PM) : Propaganda more

It is a government financed film so it has to be propaganda in some sort of way. That doesn’t necessarily has to be a bad thing but it’s good to remember. It’s scripted but it tries to be as faithful as in the way people used to talk (older English) and you can still call it a documentary I would say, because everything that’s portrayed actually happened (and a lot of people in this documentary were or had been fireman, I heard). So I would say it’s propaganda, but one that tries to stay as close to the truth as possible.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 12:13PM) : reality and script more

The reality is obviously what happened in Britain by the Germans. Adding spice to real-life scenarios by editing each scenes, that is scripted. This makes the film a bit more dramatic and gives viewer better understanding to the event.

profile_photo
May 20
Errol Lewis Errol Lewis (May 20 2016 3:23PM) : It's hard to say what is scripted and what is reality because the lines have been crossed several times throughout the years more

But in this film, scripted is the visualisation of events and the message the documentary tries to portray. At the same time, we come to realize the reality of the situation by taking our own step back and viewing the documentary from a different perspective than the one we’re expected.

profile_photo
May 23
Colon Greene Colon Greene (May 23 2016 1:28PM) : By splicing together the use of script and reality the film was able to create a sense of crediblity that would have been lacking from a completely scripted movie. more

By splicing together the use of script and reality the film was able to create a sense of crediblity that would have been lacking from a completely scripted movie.

New Thinking Partner Conversation New Conversation
Paragraph 6, Sentence 1 0
No sentence-level conversations. Start one.

DMU Timestamp: December 23, 2015 22:09

General Document Comments 0
New Thinking Partner Conversation Start a new Document-level conversation

profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:13PM) : What is the role of natural sound in this film?
profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:28PM) : The natural sound used in the film works in compliance with the film's intention to "observe." The contributes to the "realism" the film is trying to convey in everyday life. Whether it includes the sounds of intense bombings or people walking more

in the street, its important to depict life as its naturally being lived by people in the film.

profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:14AM) : Good points
profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 1:10AM) : Stronger connection to the characters. more

The use of natural sound makes lets you believe your hearing what the characters in the film are hearing. Your not just a viewer anymore, but another worker at this fire station. It make you feel more invested in their fates.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:18AM) : Yes, the natural sound brings you closer to those in the scene.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 3:14PM) : Natural Sounds more

When firefighters have their dinner and are waiting call, they are joking, laughing, and singing. These are not just attempting to waste their time. I can feel their emotions. They are trying to enjoy as much as possible before the crisis, which they do not know when it is coming. Thus I think the natural sound brings audience closer to understanding their feelings.

profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:16PM) : The natural sound contributes to the realism of the film.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:35AM) : As it does for all films more

Realistic and environmental sounds can be misconstrued because what is realistic isn’t always what sound is occurring at the moment.

profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 2:42PM) : natural sound more

I think the role of the natural sound strengthens the realism in Jennings’ film. That being said what we are hearing in the film is not only natural sound, as there is music in the film which adjusts depending on the scene.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:14AM) : Right. The film takes advantage of natural sound but also scripted action and music
profile_photo
May 13
William Prystup William Prystup (May 13 2016 11:35AM) : Distinguishing Emotions more

I think the role of natural sound in this film is to separate and distinguish different emotions. For example a bombing runs sound gives the viewer an intense feeling, while when the firefighters aren’t in action, they’re acting casually before they have to go to work. That gives the viewer a feeling of calmness. That to me represents how fast emotions can change in a situation of war. From casual jokes while eating to complete alertness. I believe that was an incentive when creating this film.

profile_photo
May 14
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 14 2016 7:58AM) : Natural sound makes the film seem more authentic, less the product of just moviemaking.
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 2:04PM) : natural sound more

I think it has to do with the ‘observing’ part. To stay as close to the truth as possible by showing the sounds of how it must have sounded during that time in the war, where people had to fight and had this fear and how that must have been like.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 12:22PM) : natural sound more

The role of natural sound in this film makes viewers feel like they are also part of in the scenes.

profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:13PM) : What is the importance of singing in this film? What are the songs about?
profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 12:42AM) : Keeping morale up more

Singing songs in a quiet time was an easy way to pass the time as they wait for an emergency. Many of the songs were very upbeat to keep morale high. They are putting out fires during war time and know some of them may not come back after some jobs. The toll it can take losing a brother in arms can take a toll on each fireman. Keeping morale up, even if it’s just singing a song, is a very important thing to do.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:15AM) : Some of the songs sounded upbeat, but they were also about death and loss.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 9:13PM) : Death and loss in an upbeat tune may just be to bring some joy to a sad thing. Like Ring around the Rosie. It's about the plague, but doesn't really sound all that sad.
profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:11PM) : Yes, acknowledging death and disaster but refusing to be downcast.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:36AM) : Tempo more

Tempo can have everything and nothing to do with the feeling of a song. Sometimes it’s best to stick with if it’s a major or minor key, which usually is telling of the mood being happy or sad respectively.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (Apr 30 2016 3:25PM) : Singing more

I think that singing can be assumed as a kind of work songs. Firefighters sing to keep their spirits up, and to have a time for enjoyment, which they never know when it ends. Singing shows not only their feelings of fear, but also their encouragement. So, it takes an important part of film.

profile_photo
May 1
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 01 2016 8:17PM) : The singing is a way of coping with the anxiety and danger.
profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:38AM) : Very True more

Song is a great tool to use in times of struggle. Mostly all cultures develop some sort of singing or music when times are tough. But most importantly people also do this in times of serenity. Strange how musical people are instinctively.

profile_photo
May 12
Ramiro Thompson Ramiro Thompson (May 12 2016 6:11PM) : Songs after a fire is a cultural thing more

yes I agree, if you look throughout history after every large fire we see people doing the same thing. It has been apart of many cultures and subcultures

profile_photo
May 13
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 13 2016 8:15AM) : Right
profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 3:30PM) : singing more

In the firefighting business it is not if you will be called to action, it is just a matter of when and I am speculating that it is usually sooner rather than later. Therefore with such a daunting task that is soon to come, it is just way for those gentlemen to calm their worries and enjoy time with their buddies. Despite it being a sad song, which the average viewer today will probably not pick up on, I think the emphasis should be placed on the way the song sounds, which is happy, a much better way to go into a dangerous task than being completely filled with nerves.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:15AM) : Of course at the time of filming most viewers would have know the song and might have sung it too
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 2:06PM) : singing more

To create togetherness. I think I’ve already kind of answered it in another question but just to mention it again: Before the fighting starts, the men are singing a song next to a piano, about dying. It’s almost some sort of tradition, it has been going on for years. ’Don’t miss me when I’m gone’ they sing. It’s some sort of togetherness, a community singing. They did it (I think) for strength and show that they were all in this together.

profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 12:34PM) : importance of singing more

The importance of singing in this film is showing how they devoted to the war. They don’t know how they will end up – there is nervousness but up beat song also gives the sense of bravery.

profile_photo
Dec 23
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Dec 23 2015 5:14PM) : Why does the film begin so quietly--some would say even boringly?
profile_photo
Apr 14
Wilde Diaz Wilde Diaz (Apr 14 2016 11:47AM) : Being loud by doing nothing. more

The use of quiet, mundane scenes at the beginning should be interpreted as the tranquility that existed before Germany decided to bomb the living hell out of Britain. In a way how there is a calm before a storm, the same is shown in this film in order to build on the suspense and tragedy that occurs during the bombing.

profile_photo
Apr 15
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 15 2016 7:35AM) : Right
profile_photo
Apr 21
Tracy Shu Tracy Shu (Apr 21 2016 3:30PM) : The film begins quietly to draw a stark contrast between what life is before the war/ fighting occurs vs. during. This is done to show the drastic impact war can have on people's lives as we hear the transgression from quiet to loud bombings.
profile_photo
Apr 22
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 22 2016 7:15AM) : And how people are able to make the transition from peace to war.
profile_photo
Apr 30
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (Apr 30 2016 12:23AM) : Everyday people more

The film starts off boringly because these firefighters are just everyday citizens. Their lives aren’t filled with 24/7 excitement. Instead, a lot of it is waiting for when they are needed.

profile_photo
Apr 30
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (Apr 30 2016 11:14AM) : I doubt those watching the film at the time thought it was boring, but I take your point.
profile_photo
May 19
Richard Caamano Richard Caamano (May 19 2016 10:16PM) : I just thought that people would think this was something audience all go through. A normal walk to work.
profile_photo
May 4
Joshua Wolfe Joshua Wolfe (May 04 2016 3:35PM) : Beginning of Film more

I think that it is just a normal way to start a film. Even today we see it. Jennings understands that you don’t just immediately jump into the action. You need to build up to that, which then makes those dramatic and action filled scenes even better.

profile_photo
May 5
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 05 2016 8:16AM) : Sometimes films just jump into action but that would defeat the director's purpose in this case
profile_photo
May 12
Ramiro Thompson Ramiro Thompson (May 12 2016 6:23PM) : True more

yes this is true and that’s what I was getting at earlier

profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:40AM) : Not in documentary more

Starting in medias res is not really a staple of documentary. That technique usually reserves itself for action or thriller type movies.

profile_photo
May 12
Ramiro Thompson Ramiro Thompson (May 12 2016 6:14PM) : Calmness more

It is probably a way not to bombard the audience and to allow them to mellow in and engage more as the film progress. When some films being with too much action and so many things occurring it throws people off. Also one would say that’s how films at that time was done

profile_photo
May 13
Carl Rollyson Carl Rollyson (May 13 2016 8:16AM) : begin?
profile_photo
May 19
Kim Brands Kim Brands (May 19 2016 2:08PM) : why more

I think they’ve done that to make you slow down, listen and reflect. The silence is its power I think, because sometimes silence can send a stronger message then the loudest sound.

profile_photo
May 20
Rich Koos Rich Koos (May 20 2016 10:41AM) : Very true, sometimes a collective silence is louder than a thousand screams.
profile_photo
May 20
yoshiko yoshida yoshiko yoshida (May 20 2016 12:41PM) : the beginning more

I think the film begin so quietly to show the daily-life of British people. And it contrasts well with the scenes later and show Jennings’ purpose in this film.

profile_photo
May 20
Jinyoung Kim Jinyoung Kim (May 20 2016 1:34PM) : the use of silence more

Sometimes the use of silence can provide the audience with feelings of tension and strong messages. Jennings uses it with a certain purpose, which makes the audience focus on the film.

Image
0 comments, 0 areas
add area
add comment
change display
Video
add comment

Quickstart: Commenting and Sharing

How to Comment
  • Click icons on the left to see existing comments.
  • Desktop/Laptop: double-click any text, highlight a section of an image, or add a comment while a video is playing to start a new conversation.
    Tablet/Phone: single click then click on the "Start One" link (look right or below).
  • Click "Reply" on a comment to join the conversation.
How to Share Documents
  1. "Upload" a new document.
  2. "Invite" others to it.

Logging in, please wait... Blue_on_grey_spinner