NowComment
Document: Invite Print Info
2-Pane Combined
Comments:
Full Summaries Sorted

Computer Assisted Instruction to Teach Item Select

Technology Use by Students with

Intellectual Disabilities: An Overview

MICHAEL L. WEHMEYER

SEAN J. SMITH

SUSAN B. PALMER

UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS

DANIEL K. DAVIES

ABLELINK TECHNOLOGIES

Technology is a prevalent feature of educational environments today. Unfortunately, in too many cases students with intellectual disabilities do not have access to or are not able to use such technologies. This article overviews the literature pertaining to the use of technology by students with intellectual disabilities, examines characteristics of this population that impact technology use, and provides a review of the literature pertaining to technology use by students with intellectual disabilities across several functional domain areas.

The U.S. Department of Education report “Computer and Internet Use by Children and Adolescents” (National Center on Educational Statistics, 2001) illustrated the degree to which technology use, particularly electronic and information technologies like computers and the Internet, has become a pervasive part of the educational process. This study found:

  1. About 90% of children and adolescents ages 5–17 (47 million) use computers and about 59% (31 million) use the Internet.

  1. About three-quarters of 5-year-olds use computers, and over 90% of teens (ages 13–17) do so. About 25% of 5-year-olds use the Internet, and this number rises to over 50% by age 9 and to at least 75% by ages 15–17.

  1. More children and adolescents use computers at school (81%) than at home (65%). (NCES, 2001, p. iv). Unfortunately, the National Center on Educational

Statistics (NCES) also found that 5 to 17-year-olds without a disability were significantly more likely to use computers and the Internet than their peers with disabilities. Furthermore, even among students with disabilities it is likely that students with intellectual disabilities are less likely to have access to and benefit from technology. The reasons for this are varied, certainly, but essentially there have been few efforts to ensure that computers and other technology devices are cognitively accessible. The National Council on Disability (1996) noted:

“…other than trying to make computers generally easier to use, no specific features targeted at users with cognitive / language impairments are known to be part of current computer design, nor have any been included in any of

the design guidelines that would not have been included in the set of guidelines for making products easier to use by this population.”

This article overviews technology use by students with intellectual disabilities, with a particular focus on electronic and information technologies, such as computers, that are widely used in education. Issues pertaining to barriers to such use for this population are also examined.

TECHNOLOGY USE BY STUDENTS WITH

INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES

There are only a few studies examining the degree to which students with intellectual disabilities use technology. Derer, Polsgrove, and Rieth (1996) investigated assistive technology (AT) use in classrooms by surveying teachers who worked with students with disabilities. These researchers found that students with intellectual disabilities constituted between 10% and 23% of students with disabilities using AT, and that 34% of students with intellectual disabilities were using some form of AT. Derer and colleagues identified six barriers to technology use for students with disabilities, including locating and procuring equipment, lack of time for training students and teachers to use the equipment as well as time to obtain and prepare equipment for use, high cost of devices and the lack of funds to access devices or services, and teacher knowledge about and training in the area of assistive technology.

The Arc, a national association on intellectual disabilities, conducted a national survey of parents regarding the use of technology by their school-age son or daughter with

Journal of Special Education Technology. 19(4), Fall 20047

Journal of Special Education Technology

an intellectual disability (Wehmeyer, 1999). The survey consisted of five areas of questions focusing on the use of technology for a specific purpose: (a) mobility technology devices, (b) hearing and vision technology devices, (c) communication technology devices, (d) home adaptations, and (e) environmental control and independent living devices. An additional set of questions tapped into the student's use of personal computers. Specifically, the survey solicited information about technology use in each functional area and computer use and availability, unmet needs with regard to each of the functional areas and computer use, barriers to technology use, training to use the technology, and satisfaction with technology use.

Although a wide array of devices were used by students with intellectual disabilities, the most striking finding was that in four of the five use-specific areas, the percentage of students who could potentially benefit from assistive devices but did not currently have access to such devices was greater than the percentage of students who currently used such devices. Cost was the greatest barrier identified, followed by information about devices and device complexity.

With regard to computer use, 68% of respondents indicated there was a computer in their home, and an additional 15% indicated that their son or daughter had access to a computer in another environment, mostly in school programs. When asked to identify what the student with an intellectual disability did with the computer, most noted educational activities. For respondents whose family member did not use computers either at home or elsewhere, 78% indicated they believed that their family member could benefit from a computer. The most frequently cited barrier to computer use was the cost or lack of funds, followed by the lack of training available, lack of information about what the computer could do to benefit the family member, the complexity of the device, and the lack of assessment.

In summary, The Arc’s survey found that students with intellectual disabilities generally underutilized technology. In most functional-use areas, more students who might benefit from assistive technology devices did not have them than students who did. Device cost, training, assessment, and complexity were identified as primary barriers. Encouragingly, however, 83% of students had access to a computer somewhere, although the range of activities for which these computers were used was limited. The survey did not determine Internet use, but as explored subsequently, there is reason to believe that many people with cognitive disabilities have only limited access to the Internet.

BARRIERS TO TECHNOLOGY USE BY STUDENTS

WITH INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES

There are several reasons students with intellectual disabilities do not use technology, but two seem particularly

important; the characteristics of students with intellectual disabilities that limit their technology use and the lack of universal design features that take into account issues of cognitive accessibility.

CHARACTERISTICS OF LEARNERS WITH INTELLECTUAL

DISABILITY THAT IMPACT TECHNOLOGY USE

The Arc’s study focused mainly on barriers external to the learner, like funding, training, or maintenance. However, one of these external barriers, device complexity, is in essence a function of learner characteristics and the abilities students bring to bear in using technology. Characteristics of learners with intellectual disabilities typically involve impairments in the following cognitive ability domains: (a) language, communication, and auditory reception, (b) reasoning, idea production, and cognitive speed, (c) memory and learning, (d) visual perception, and, (e) knowledge and achievement (Carroll, 1993).

In general, to promote technology use by students in this population, educators need to consider issues pertaining to these areas of limitation in cognitive abilities and ensure that technology adequately addresses them. We have recently conducted comprehensive examinations of the impact of these limitations on technology use by students and adults with intellectual disabilities (Wehmeyer, Smith, and Davies, in press; Wehmeyer, Smith, Palmer, Davies, & Stock, 2004) and briefly summarize the findings from these examinations in this section.

Language and Communication Ability and Auditory Reception

Impairments in language and communication ability impact technology use in several ways. Impairments in receptive and expressive communication skills limit the degree to which some students with intellectual disabilities will be able to utilize technology, particularly the expanding class of telecommunication technologies. Additionally, a growing means of inputting information used by technology (e.g., computer programs) involves speech input devices. Problems of speech articulation pose barriers in both cases, but other factors pose problems with these and other technologies. Similarly, more complex verbal instructions, such as those often found in voice mail systems, may limit use for people with cognitive impairments.

Impairments in reading and writing abilities also introduce barriers to effective technology use. The most obvious is often that the primary input mode to access a wide array of computer technology involves typing or, with newer handwriting transcription technologies, writing abilities. Even when input is not required, most software programs require rather high levels of reading ability to navigate. Many instructions to technology use and maintenance are written,

8Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

often in overly complex formats that people with intellectual disabilities cannot read or understand. Although the technology field is increasingly embracing the use of more universally accepted graphics to communicate information, most technology continues to rely primarily on text to present program options and provide instructions to users.

Technology devices often emit tones and other sounds intended to convey meaning. Often, however, it is difficult to discern their meaning even for experienced technology users. With computers, the audio signal is many times accompanied by a text message in a message box or somewhere else on the computer screen. Technology developers generally assume the ability for users to read the accompanying text message. The need to read to understand the meaning of the audio signal thus limits the number of users with intellectual disabilities who can understand the computer-generated message.

The language involved in technology use is often not consistent with that of everyday communication. Terminology used in some technology systems is often complex and may introduce new definitions of common terms. For example, a menu in a computer program, while conceptually similar (i.e., an array of choices) to the common use of menu at a restaurant, may confuse a student with an intellectual disability. Many examples of these language-related barriers can be identified by considering the terms used in common software applications (e.g., file, tools, window, drive). Use of terms with multiple meanings and abstract metaphors (e.g., files, folders) can pose barriers to people with intellectual disabilities, who respond to language based on a more literal, concrete representation of the world.

Reasoning, Idea Production, and Cognitive Speed

Reasoning abilities involve capacities in areas such as sequential reasoning (i.e., deductive, logical, and verbal reasoning, symbol manipulation, match problems), inductive ability (i.e., requiring a person to inspect a class of stimulus materials to infer a common characteristic), and quantitative reasoning (e.g., those requiring reasoning based on mathematical properties and relations, including critical evaluation, arithmetic reasoning and problem solving, math aptitude, and number series, classification and operations). Idea Production refers to abilities required for individuals to produce ideas and communicate them, including ideational fluency, naming facility (i.e., naming common concepts), associational fluency (i.e., producing words/concept that are associated), expressional fluency, word fluency, sensitivity to problems, originality/creativity, figural fluency (i.e., producing original drawings or sketches), and figural flexibility (i.e., solving figurative problems).

In that these domains encompass abilities that are considered to be at or near the core of what is ordinarily meant by intelligence, it follows that they significantly impact the

ability of students with intellectual disabilities to use technology. For example, virtually all appliances, devices, and software systems require some level of sequential reasoning, even if it is as simple as having the ability to assess whether the system is turned on or not. This may be true for a wide range of simple to complex technologies, from knowing whether the iron is on, to activating an augmentative communication system. To the more complex side of things, most computer programs are complex and interactive, requiring the user to constantly take actions and draw conclusions from the system’s reaction as to what is the most likely next move.

The impact of limitations in numeracy on technology use can also be seen in the many systems that involve numerical comprehension and manipulation. From setting a stove temperature and dialing a telephone to using calculators and entering data, situations abound where limitations in numeracy skills impact technology use. Limitations in this area can be compensated for by providing non-numerical interventions to improve access, such as in picture-based speed dial telephones or special markings on dials or switches to cue the user to a specific setting or switch when many choices are available.

Mainstream computer programs invariably offer a myriad of interface choices at any given time, many of them providing multiple input options for the same output (e.g., text menu, key board shortcuts, button toolbars). Specialized computer programs can be created that utilize a limited number of repetitive processes that are largely linear in nature. This means that at any given time while interacting with the software either a single choice is available for the next step, or system-generated cues such as audio prompts guide the user to the next-most-likely action. Other examples of limiting choice options to make technologies more accessible include desktop software that provides access to a limited set of computer features or augmentative communication device and keyboard overlays that reduce or reprogram available keys.

Other technologies present their own challenges to the capacity of students with cognitive impairments to reason abstractly. Communication devices often include customizable pictures or text buttons that, when pressed, speak the indicated word or phrase. To provide added functionality, most of these devices include a feature that allows the user to create different overlays, or layers, so that more words or phrases can be accessed. For example, a typical device may have 16 buttons that can be programmed to speak a designated phrase. But an additional switch allows the user to activate another layer of programming so that the same 16 buttons can speak entirely different phrases. However, many of these devices are not usable by students with mental retardation, due in part to the inability to conceive of these different layers.

Wehmeyer9

Journal of Special Education Technology

Other examples may be as simple as failure to recognize or understand the meaning of when the computer cursor arrow turns into a hand icon when it is placed over a clickable element of a Web site, or in understanding the difference between a single click, a double click or a right-click. Even the most basic of software features—such as in the practice of disabling or graying-out buttons when they have no practical use—often are too subtle to be recognized by users with cognitive disabilities.

Using technology on a regular basis often entails problem identification and problem solving by the technology user that may serve as a barrier to people with intellectual disabilities. Many technology users rely on their ability to generalize previous learning to problem solve unexpected occurrences. However, many individuals with intellectual disabilities have limited ability to generalize learning from one situation to another and therefore do not develop the workaround strategies that users of technology develop to overcome problems. This may be due to the learning demands related to the acquisition of knowledge and skills to use a program or device, lack of experience with the technology, excessive complexity, poor interface design, program or system bugs and failures, or conflicts with other technologies.

Cognitive Speed abilities include skills in areas such as rate-of-test-taking and reaction time. Limitations in these abilities may impact technology use. Current technology devices generally have ample processing power, and do not require users to wait for very long for actions to be accomplished. One exception, however, is the area of utilizing dynamic content and applications delivered over the Internet. While access speeds are increasing rapidly, there still can be delays when using Web applications due to the type of connection as well as the type of media being delivered (e.g., streaming audio and video). The inability to detect when to wait for a program or Web page to catch up after making user inputs can lead to errors as users may click buttons multiple times waiting for the program to do what it is supposed to do, without realizing that the first button press was sufficient.

The ability to respond quickly to operate technology devices can also be an important factor in technology operations for students with intellectual disabilities. For example, some ATMs require users to make inputs within very short time spans. If a person is slow at making an input, the ATM will either display a text message such as “Do you want to continue?” — which many people with intellectual disabilities would not be able to read — or may simply end the activity. Some ATMs, when expelling the ATM card for the user to take, sound an audio tone for a short time and, if the card is not taken quickly, the card may be taken back into the machine and kept. Cognitive speed limitations that impair a student’s ability to use technology fast enough can introduce barriers to technology use.

Memory and Learning Skills

Mainstream technology interfaces are often complex as developers seek to provide users with a wide array of program features that, in the end, require the student to learn and remember multiple steps to complete a process. Too often this occurs at the expense of simplicity of use. Thus, while many students without cognitive disabilities may find these interfaces challenging, their complexity often renders the technology system unusable by students with intellectual disabilities. For example, many students with intellectual disabilities have difficulty performing personal budgeting activities independently. There are now several commercially available software programs that automate the functions associated with balancing a checkbook, paying bills online, and maintaining a budget. With such supports, students with intellectual disabilities may only need to be taught how to input data, as opposed to the skills related to math, which are less attainable for many students. However, almost without exception, the interfaces for these software programs are too complex and confusing for use by people with cognitive impairments and, in the end, they are unable to use them to perform the function for which they are intended.

When considering technology supports for students with memory and learning limitations, technology designers must provide intuitive interfaces without overwhelming students with too many options. Often it is better to provide a single, consistent approach to performing a program function than providing multiple methods for accomplishing the same task. For example, in most Windows-based word processing systems, computer users can copy and paste text in a variety of ways: (a) highlighting the text and making appropriate selections [edit – copy – edit – paste] from the text toolbar and dropdown menu, (b) highlighting the text and clicking on the copy icon on the toolbar, followed by the paste icon, or (c) highlighting text and right-clicking on the highlighted text, then selecting copy and paste from that menu. Such a range of options may be too complex for some students with intellectual disability for whom it may be simpler to stick to one modality (e.g., using the icons on the toolbar) across multiple task activities. In general, devices that require users to memorize and learn long sequences of commands to succeed present barriers for students with intellectual disabilities.

Visual Perception Abilities

Visual Perception Abilities refer to the cognitive component of vision (i.e., as opposed to impairments to sensation, such as blindness), including impairments in visualization, spatial relations, closure speed (i.e., the ability to combine disparate visual stimuli into a meaningful whole), closure flexibility (i.e., ability to manipulate, visually, multiple objects or configurations, such as hidden figure tasks), serial

10Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

perceptual integration (i.e., integrating sequential images), spatial scanning (i.e., speed in exploring a visual field), perceptual speed (i.e., speed of finding desired images or stimuli), imagery (i.e., ability to image or visualize performance or action sequence), length estimation, perception of illusion, and perceptual alternations. These factors relate to the abilities in “searching the visual field, apprehending the forms, shapes, and positions of objects as visually perceived, [and] forming mental representations” (Carroll, p. 304).

Limitations in visual perceptual ability can have a significant impact on one’s capacity to operate software programs and in particular, software operating systems. As graphical user interfaces using pointing devices such as a mouse or touchpad have evolved and become the dominant mode of interacting with computers, the ability to scan, locate and act upon key information on the display screen has become of paramount importance. Attending to relevant environmental cues can often be difficult for students with intellectual disabilities, and this difficulty also exists when viewing complex displays, with potentially many windows, buttons, and other screen elements. Larger computer monitors combined with increasing display resolutions provide the capability to populate the computer display with many windows and graphical elements including icons, menus, and other images. Without careful attention, screen clutter can be very distracting and can make managing a computer session very difficult or impossible for users with visual spatial limitations

Another significant limitation can result from difficulty mastering the skill of moving the mouse or other pointing devices and associating that with moving the arrow or pointer on screen. With most computers, the predominant input control device is a mouse, trackball, or touchpad. The ability to successfully correlate hand movements with the movement of the arrow on screen is necessary to use these standard input devices. Touch screens are often a good alternative given their direct cause effect function, but they are still more expensive and are not standard equipment with off-the-shelf commercial systems. In addition, touch screens are only useful if the software applications that will be used have a user interface designed with larger buttons and controls to allow them to be selected with a finger on the display.

Additionally, visual perceptual impairments can impact a student’s interactions with virtually any type of technology device, including difficulty in following instructions for the device use, difficulty with operating device controls, and so forth.

Knowledge and Achievement Abilities

Knowledge and achievement abilities involve general school achievement, verbal information and knowledge, information and knowledge in mathematics and science,

technical and mechanical knowledge, and knowledge of behavioral content (personal-social interaction knowledge). Computers are common tools for acquiring new knowledge and generating new works of achievement and are used to learn about nearly any topic as well as to produce, such as in writing, composing music, or generating artistic works. The majority of software applications that have been used for students with intellectual disabilities to acquire new knowledge or abilities have been developed for other groups, primarily for children. Thus, age-appropriateness has often been absent when it comes to learning software for students with intellectual disabilities, as few applications have been designed with the appropriate user interfaces and with ranges of appropriate content. Early reading or basic math programs may be beneficial for some students, but generally the programs that are available are not age-appropriate for older students and adults with intellectual disabilities.

Programs for writing, such as word processors, may be useful for a minority of users with intellectual disabilities who have attained some level of literacy skills. Better success may be achieved in using painting and graphics programs, although these vary greatly in complexity of operation. Simpler-to-use drawing programs allow users with intellectual disabilities a vehicle for artistic expression, but there are also barriers to independent use. Mouse skills are usually required, which often presents a barrier. Alternative input devices can be used effectively, however, including graphics tablets or touch screens. Saving files and printing the finished product may also be difficult as menus and print options may be difficult to navigate. There appears to be a great opportunity for innovation in the area of creating software applications that can be used independently by individuals with various levels of cognitive ability to generate creative content.

FEATURES OF TECHNOLOGY THAT

ADDRESS USER CHARACTERISTICS

Universal Design

Journal of Special Education Technology (JSET) readers will be familiar with the principles of universal design as applied to technology design, including equitable use, flexibility in use, simple and intuitive use, perceptible information, tolerance for error, low physical effort, and size and space for approach and appropriate use (The Center for Universal Design, 1997). If all technology devices took into account all of these principles, it is quite likely that many more devices would be useable by students with intellectual disabilities.

However, several might be particularly important in light of the previous discussion on cognitive abilities and the impact of limitations in these areas on technology use. First,

Wehmeyer11

Journal of Special Education Technology

devices that abide by the flexibility in use principle inherently accommodate for use by a wider range of individual preferences and abilities. This includes providing options that accommodate for users’ accuracy and precision, and adapt to a user’s pace. For example, computer programs providing multiple input and output options (e.g., auditory, visual, icon) fit this category, as do telephones that have larger buttons with more space between numbers (The Center for Universal Design, 1997). Issues of simplicity and intuitiveness of use are obviously important for students with intellectual disabilities. As noted previously, many devices are overly complex and operate counter to users’ expectations, including common appliances such as VCRs and alarm clocks. Universally-designed devices also typically provide some supports (prompting, graphic, visual, or audio directions) for use. The principle of perceptible information requires not only that information needed to operate the device be easily seen, but also that such information be provided in multiple modes, with redundant presentation of information.

Finally, an important and often overlooked feature for students with intellectual disabilities is the principle of tolerance for error. As noted previously, students with intellectual disabilities frequently make mistakes in using technology and if that error results in a failed use, the device becomes essentially impossible for students to use. Developing technology that never encounters unexpected errors is virtually impossible. However, given the difficulty many students with intellectual disabilities have responding to unexpected errors, it is imperative that priority be placed on identifying highly reliable technology supports for these students. Device failure is often a function of device complexity. The more complex a device is and the more features it has, the more likely it is to have unexpected errors. At times it may be more important to identify less complex devices with fewer features if they provide the benefit of greater reliability. Moreover, many devices have, in essence, a one-strike-and-you’re-out policy where one error (e.g., wrong key stroke, wrong button) results in the failure of the user’s session. For example, the value of a dialogue box that prompts you to confirm a selection (e.g., deletion, exit) becomes evident when you inadvertently hit the exit icon without having saved work on an ongoing activity. The dialogue box allows you to select Cancel and does not immediately delete unsaved work. Students with intellectual disabilities need devices that minimize the potential for error, but also which allow errors to occur without dire consequences.

Another example of how features of technology address the characteristics of users with intellectual disabilities involves recommendations from the Telecommunications Access Committee (1999), which was commissioned to look at engineering and design features that would ensure access to telecommunications technology for people with cognitive

disabilities. This committee identified four classes of strategies that achieve this: (a) redundant, user-controlled modality of information, (b) streamlined, user-controlled amount and rate of information, (c) procedural support, and

(c) content organization.

Strategies to ensure that the device design contains redundant, user-controlled information include the use of visual examples (e.g., diagrams, graphic icons, line drawings), in addition to or instead of text, providing information both in visual and auditory formats, providing descriptions of pictures, captions, and so forth, and allowing multiple methods that allow users to locate and use controls (e.g., shape, size, texture, color, labels, voice output) (TAC, 1999). Allowing users to control the amount and rate of information and streamlining information provided is the second strategy identified. Such strategies support students with attention and memory limitations by allowing a user to control aspects (i.e., size, placement, appearance) of display elements, by providing simple, standardized layouts for devices and controls, presenting information in a step-by-step fashion, keeping needed information available until the user dismisses it instead of timing display changes such as information on the screen of a digital phone, eliminating functions that require simultaneous action, providing mechanisms to speed up, slow down, or repeat information, and using select-and-confirm strategies that involve users confirming they have completed a step in the process (TAC, 1999). Procedural support strategies address executive function, planning, and sequencing issues, reducing memory load and limiting distraction. Such strategies include providing step-by-step instructions, cue sequences and feedback cues in multiple formats, the use of wizards to offer help and support operation, and automating more complex aspects of the technology use (e.g., storing phone numbers in memory). Finally, content strategies include keeping language simple, highlighting key information or providing summaries of information, and so forth.

TECHNOLOGY USE BY STUDENTS WITH

INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES: LITERATURE REVIEW

Technology use relevant to students with intellectual disabilities will, necessarily, go beyond how technology is used in the classroom, primarily because the educational programs of students with intellectual disabilities involve content in both core academic content areas and in functional, life skills areas offered in school and in the community. So, in addition to the use of technology for traditional instructional purposes, such as computer assisted instruction, to promote academic progress and achievement, students with disabilities can benefit from technology to support learning in a wide array of life skills areas. In this section we examine the literature pertaining to the use of technology by students with

12Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

intellectual disabilities within seven functional use areas: (a) communication, (b) mobility, (c) environmental control, (d) activities of daily living and community inclusion, (e) education, (f) employment, and (g) recreation and leisure.

Communication

Being able to communicate is, of course, a critical skill that facilitates student interactions with others, including peers and adults, and enables students to meet their basic needs. Romski and Sevick (1988) noted that the field has adopted a broad definition of communication, including vocalizations, gestures, and other modes of expression, from among which technology plays a central role. A number of research studies have identified the importance of using technology to provide alternative means of communication for persons with multiple and cognitive impairments (Blischak, 1999; Meyers, 1994; Schepis, Reid, Behrmann & Sutton, 1998).

Augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) involves the use of technology in the form of voice output communication aids (VOCA) and synthesized speech, but may also include a wide array of options for communication from low-tech message boards, signing, symbols, pictures and visual prompts to very complex technology (Blamires, 1999; Blischak & Lloyd, 1996; Hooper & Hasselbring, 1985).

Sigafoos and Ianoco (1993) suggested that, in selecting such a device, a student and his or her family, in conjunction with a wider team of related services personnel, should look at such factors as symbol options (e.g., real objects, photographs or line drawings); the representation of the message and how that message is accessed (e.g., direct selection, eye gaze, scanning); the options for output such as visual or speech output; and the expandability/ portability of the device, related to storage capacity for communication units and the size/weight of the device.

Research concerning AAC and individuals with intellectual disabilities has focused on diverse, but related aspects of the communication process, including communicative intent (Dicarlo & Banajee, 2000), social interaction (Abrahamson, Romski & Sevcik, 1989), functional communication (Dyches, 1998), symbol recognition (Abrahamson, et al., 1989), and communication to encourage positive behavior support (Danquah, Mate-Kole & Zehr, 1996). Dicarlo and Banajee (2000) evaluated the effects of VOCA devices for young children with significant developmental delays who were not verbal. The Alpha Talker (Prentke-Romich) and a Dual Rocking Lever Switch (Enabling Devices) using Picture Communication Symbols (Mayer-Johnson) were used with two children who were two-years-old. Increased communication initiations were found for these children following baseline observation and training on the use of one of these devices for each child. At any age,

VOCA devices: (a) lessen the burden on the listener, (b) serve as a means of getting attention, rather than having to gain attention first before communication starts, and (c) facilitate typical communication by storing messages in advance (Dicarlo & Banajee, 2000; Mustonen, Locke, Reichle, Solbrack & Londgren, 1991). Use of AAC technology has also been shown to improve speech comprehension, speech production, improved attention span, visual attention in a visual-motor task, and improved social interaction in a study conducted with children with intellectual disabilities (Abrahamson, et al., 1989).

Studies have shown the benefit of people with intellectual disabilities using a simple switch to produce functional communication using a tape-recorded message (Dyches, 1998) or to signal the need to continue an activity (Gee, Graham, Goetz, Oshima & Yoshioka, 1991). They have also been shown as effective to support a person to demonstrate a preference or make requests for activities (Wacker, Wiggins, Fowler & Berg, 1988).

Computers can be useful as AAC devices for individuals with intellectual disabilities. Hetzroni, Rubin and Konkol (2002) showed that a classroom PC was used effectively as AAC incorporating eye gaze technology for young girls with Rett Syndrome. Similarly, the System for Augmenting Language (SAL); (Romski & Sevcik, 1996) instructional approach uses computer-based speech output devices to pair symbols with English words. Partners in communicative interactions learn to use the device to augment their speech input to the participant’s symbol input, and ongoing resources and feedback to support both communication partners are put in place.

Mobility

Limitations in mobility have implications for most functional life areas, such as employment, recreation, and community inclusion. Despite the pervasiveness of limitations related to mobility among people with intellectual disabilities, there is little research evaluating the use of technology applications to the problem and, in most cases, this literature base has focused only on adult populations, typically adults with cognitive disabilities who are aging and losing ambulation. Nevertheless, some of this research has potential implications for students.

For example, Lancioni, Olivia, and Gnocchini (1996) taught two adults with intellectual disabilities and visual impairments to use a radio/light system to assist in indoor travel in familiar and unfamiliar environments. The device was capable of turning the lights on as the user approached, and subsequently turning them off as the user passed a light source. Researchers programmed both the device and light sources for the appropriate route during test sessions. Results demonstrated that not only were the two subjects able to use

Wehmeyer13

Journal of Special Education Technology

the system to orient and move independently in the familiar environment, they were also able to successfully generalize use of the light guiding system to an unfamiliar environment.

Other studies have dealt with more common mobility technologies or addressed gross motor movement for people with intellectual disabilities, as opposed to destination-based movement issues. May (1983) demonstrated that a wheelchair user with severe cognitive and physical disabilities could benefit from a switch-activated system that played music when she lifted her head into a desired position. Similarly, Horn and Warren (1987) used a computer system that activated toy reinforcers to substantially increase motor skills (e.g., pulling, kneeling, sitting up) in two young children with severe, multiple disabilities.

Activities of Daily Living, Environmental Control, and Community Integration

Technology use can support greater independence in activities of daily living, control over one’s environment, and enhanced community integration (Anderson, Sherman, Sheldon & McAdam, 1997; Felce & Emerson, 2001; Lancioni, 1994; Johnson & Miltenberger, 1996). In general, the impact of technology use on community inclusion has not been examined directly and is inferred from the capacity of technology to support greater independence in daily living activities and in environmental control, as well as the potential for technology to support greater mobility around the community.

A case study by Lancioni, O’Reilly & Campodonico (2002) supported the efficacy of audio prompts delivered via a portable tape player in reducing the time needed for a young adult with multiple disabilities to complete dressing and washing activities. Similarly, Browning and White (1986) demonstrated the efficacy of interactive video-based instructional materials to promote greater community participation and functional life skills for students with intellectual disabilities, and Langone and colleagues have shown the efficacy of video-based instructional materials to promote community integration skills like grocery shopping (Langone, Shade, Clees, & Day, 1999; Mechling, Gast, & Langone, 2002).

Riley, Bodine, Hills, Gane, Sanstrum, and Hagerman (2001) showed that use of The Tickle Box (Adaptive Learning Company), a reminder system that includes a modified pager to help people manage their own activities, by a young woman with fragile X syndrome enabled her to independently complete more daily living tasks than when she was not using the device.

Control over one’s environment is also an important component of increased independence to which technology can contribute (Hammel, 2000), though there are few studies that have examined this with regard to individuals with

intellectual disability. Lancioni, O’Reilly, Oliva, and Coppa (2001a, 2001b) showed that two boys with multiple disabilities could use microswitches to control aspects of their environment, providing a greater range of response options and opportunities for environmental input than without such switches. Hammel, Lai, and Heller (2002) conducted a longitudinal study of people with developmental disabilities who were aging, and found that a majority of persons had better function with regard to community living outcomes with the use of AT.

Education

The use of computer assisted instruction (CAI) has become more prevalent in schools, though the majority of studies examining CAI focused on commercial math and spelling programs with students with learning disabilities (Hofmeister, 1984; Higgins & Boone, 1990; Horton et al., 1988). For students with intellectual disabilities, studies of the impact of CAI have focused on basic skills and the practice and automation of these skills. Because CAI can be individualized, repetitive, and systematic in its presentation of material, it has been found to be particularly promising for providing extended practice needed to promote the automaticity of basic skills (e.g., mathematics, word recognition) (Kinney, Stevens, & Schuster, 1988).

Lin, Podell and Rein’s (1991) study of word recognition improvement typifies a series of comparisons between CAI and traditional instruction. In this study, 45 students with mild intellectual disabilities used a word attack program to strengthen word recognition skills. On the computer screen, the word was first introduced, followed by a phrase, and then a series of complete sentences. The outcome of the drill and practice CAI was an increase in the response rate for students, but no significant change in the number of correct words identified. The increased response rate was attributed to improvement in students’ ability to monitor their performance as well as the immediacy of the feedback and reinforcement in the CAI condition. Similarly, Podell, Tournaki-Rein, and Lin (1992) found a decrease on average from 22 seconds to 7 seconds for 71 individuals with a mild intellectual disabilities practicing addition. This exemplifies findings from a series of CAI studies (e.g., Margalit & Roth, 1989; Podell, Tournaki-Rein, & Lin, 1992) that found an increase in response rate but not a significant improvement in correct responses. Results are consistent across an array of academic content areas, including, addition and subtraction, word recognition, and spelling (Farmer, Klein, & Bryson, 1992).

Lin, Podell and Tournaki-Rein (1994) examined CAI and mathematic skills in students with and without intellectual disabilities. In the addition portion of their study they found minimal difference, but in the subtraction portion differences between the CAI and pencil-and-paper conditions was found.

14Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

Faster response time was reported and attributed to the inherent features of the computer-based program. Similarly, Leung (1994) found that teaching simple addition to children with intellectual disabilities using a computer could improve sustainable performance and generalize to paper-and-pencil applications and related tests.

The application of CAI to students with intellectual disabilities has also been shown to benefit skill generalization. For instance, Stevens, Blackhurst, and Slaton (1991) delivered instruction on word recognition and spelling via CAI. Student spelling and word recognition performance improved significantly and outcomes indicated that immediate generalization from computer training to teacher-directed handwritten format can occur without the need of continuous computer-assisted feedback. Likewise, Jaspers and Van Lieshout (1994) showed that students who received technology-based external modeling instruction outperformed other children.

Distinct from CAI but equally important in education is research conducted to examine the use of computers or related technologies to assist in the continued engagement of students in the learning experience or a functional task (LeGrice & Blampied, 1994). Lancioni and his colleagues conducted a series of studies to explore the effectiveness of technology and the role it can play in promoting task performance (Lancioni et al., 1999; Lancioni et al., 2000; Lancioni, O’Reilly, Campdonico, & Mantini, 2001). In these studies, an electronic device, similar to a PDA, emitted auditory and tactile prompts (i.e., vibrations) and offered step-by-step instructions in the task to be completed. Lancioni and his colleagues found that the computer-based strategy improved performance across tasks for individuals with moderate to severe intellectual disabilities.

Briggs et al., (1990) examined prompt systems for adolescents with moderate to severe intellectual disabilities focusing on a self-operated auditory prompting system. Like Lancioni and colleagues, Briggs et al. observed generalization of the use of the self-prompting device across settings as well as maintenance of the skill and the problem-solving behavior. LeGrice and Blampied (1994) integrated video prompts to support successful completion of a task. Unlike Lancioni and his colleagues, the video prompting involved preparing the individual to correctly perform the steps. The focus here was to transfer the video prompts to the personal operation of a computer.

Studies of the use of video prompting that emerged in special education technology literature during the late 1980s have examined the impact of this technology across disability categories, including students with intellectual disabilities (Woodward & Rieth, 1997). Both Cuvo and Klatt (1992) and Wissick, Lloyd, and Kinzie (1992) used multimedia technologies to assist learners with intellectual disabilities to learn to tell time, with the latter also focusing on teaching

students to understand directions, discriminate the worth of coins, and develop appropriate social skills.

From early examinations, researchers have expanded multimedia applications reflecting a constructivist approach to learning. Rather than teacher-directed instruction, multimedia-based efforts have fostered learning through media tools. According to Langone and colleagues (1999) a simple multimedia computer-based instruction program can be used to establish match-to-sample skills, as well as subsequent generalization of those skills to the natural setting for students with moderate to severe mental retardation. Using photographs of cereal boxes as part of an interactive multimedia tutorial, Langone and his colleagues increased the likelihood that selection of specified cereal boxes would generalize to the grocery store in the community.

Other studies have employed media, including video illustrations, to serve as training illustrations for understanding, application and subsequent use in the classroom or community setting (Mechling, Gast, & Langone, 2002; Morgan & Salzberg, 1992). The outcome reported by Haring et al., (1995) and others is that individuals with intellectual disabilities can learn skills via rich media-based illustrations in one setting that will generalize to another setting (e.g., community, home).

Finally, Lieber and Semmel (1989) conducted a study to examine whether grouping students impacted social and instructional interaction between children with disabilities and their typically developing peers. The purpose of the study was to compare social and instructional interaction, by way of microcomputers, based on group configuration and alterations to task difficulty. Although the primary focus was not on inclusive practices, per se, the findings from this study have implications with regard to the potential role that technology can play in promoting inclusive practices for students with mental retardation. Lieber and Semmel found that when paired with typically developing peers with the use of computer technology as the focal point, children with intellectual disabilities were more likely to interact with peers, make positive self-evaluation statements, and make negative peer-evaluation statements.

Employment

Employment is an area of both importance and dependency for people with intellectual disabilities, and technology use has become an increasingly important way to support them to gain and maintain employment. In 1987, Gaylord-Ross identified the use of instructional technology as an important element in successful supported employment efforts. While the use of technology for job training and job skill development, as emphasized by Gaylord-Ross, is still important, the emphasis in this functional area has grown to include the use of technology to provide on-the-job supports

Wehmeyer15

Journal of Special Education Technology

and real time assistance to workers with intellectual disabilities. In addition, technology is being used to teach complex job related skills that do not pertain to a specific task or activity, but rather the acquisition of positive behavioral and social skills necessary for successful employment (Storey & O’Neil, 1996; Morgan & Salzberg, 1992).

More recent examinations of technology use to improve vocational outcomes for individuals with intellectual disabilities have generally addressed two areas; improvement of specific job task performance while minimizing human supports from others (i.e., job coaches, supervisors) and improvement of social and behavioral skills related to work settings. Such applications of technology have generally yielded positive vocational outcomes (Barkvik & Martsson, 2002; Davies, Stock & Wehmeyer, 2002a; Mitchell, Collins, Shuster & Gassaway, 2000; Taber, Alberto & Frederick, 1998).

Teaching appropriate job-related social skills is an area where technology has been applied to support workers with intellectual disabilities. Mitchell and colleagues (2000) taught three students with mild intellectual disabilities to use a cassette recorder as an auditory prompting system to assist with a variety of vocational skills in a middle school. The ability of the students to learn to operate the recorder and follow the instructions was assessed, as well as the ability to generalize the acquired skills to another setting. In addition, effects on skill maintenance were assessed. Students were taught how to turn on the cassette recorder, listen to the auditory instructions while wearing headphones, and to turn off the cassette recorder after listening to the instruction and hearing a beep. Students were instructed to verbalize the step and then perform it. A multiple probe across behaviors design was used and the results demonstrated that students were able to acquire the targeted skills and that the skills did transfer to another setting.

In another study, a portable cassette recorder with step-by-step recorded prompts was used to evaluate the utility of a self-operated auditory prompting system with five school-age workers with moderate intellectual disabilities using prompts delivered in one-word or multiple word instruction segments (Taber, Alberto, & Frederick, 1998). Instructions were presented in a to-do list format. Subjects were taught to press the play button to listen to the task, and then stop the recorder in between tasks. The number of successful transitions from one task to another measured task performance, as subjects had demonstrated great difficulty moving from one task to the next independently in baseline sessions. Results showed significant improvement in the ability to change from one task to the next when using either the single or multiple word auditory prompting system. There were no significant differences found when comparing the single and multiple word auditory prompting approaches.

Computer-based prompting devices with specialized

interfaces have been applied to support vocational tasks. Davies, Stock, & Wehmeyer (2002a) evaluated the impact of a handheld computer based system designed to provide self-directed audio and picture prompts on improving task accuracy and independence in accomplishing two different vocational assembly tasks, folding pizza boxes and packaging a commercial software product. Ten adolescents and young adults with intellectual disabilities performed each task with and without the presence of the technology system. Results indicated that the computerized prompting system significantly improved task performance. In addition, these gains were achieved with significantly greater independence, as measured by the amount of assistance required from a job coach to complete each task. In addition, subjects expressed positive reactions as well as preference for using the specialized prompting system.

In addition to technology applications for providing self-directed prompting to facilitate task performance, research has also addressed use of technology to promote time management in vocational settings. Davies, Stock and Wehmeyer (2002b) described a software program running on a palmtop computer that can be used by supervisors, job coaches or educators to create a picture and audio-based scheduler that can be programmed to prompt users on specific vocational activities at a particular time or according to a pre-defined schedule of activities. At the prescribed time, the handheld computer turns itself on and alerts the student to the activity using a combination of audio and visual alarms, a picture cue representing the event, and personalized audio messages describing what the individual needs to do at the particular time. Study participants were required to initiate a number of tasks at specific times. An error was recorded if the individual failed to initiate the activity at all, if he or she did not initiate the activity within one minute of the scheduled time, or if the activity was initiated too early. Results showed significant improvement in the ability to initiate tasks on schedule in response to the prompting system as compared to baseline data.

Although studies of the application of technology in supported employment have been sparse, extant evidence suggests that technology systems, particularly those designed to address support and user interface needs of individuals with mental retardation, can improve vocational outcomes for many individuals. These outcomes can also be sustained over time, as demonstrated by Mann and Svorai (1994). Their project demonstrated successful placement of 17 of 27 persons during a three-year demonstration project of individuals who had utilized a computer training system to learn skills necessary to retain basic computer jobs.

Recreation and Leisure

Applications of technology to the area of sports,

16Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

recreation, and leisure skills has considerable promise to improve the quality of life of students with disabilities (Cain, 1984). Being able to fill spare time in purposeful ways is important to one’s quality of life. Recreational programming of age-appropriate skills can help to bridge the gap between students with and without disabilities for inclusion in community settings (Sedlak, Doyle & Schloss, 1982).

Toy use by children with intellectual disabilities has been studied extensively. Particularly for young children with multiple cognitive and sensory disabilities, toys using switches and other technologies encourage play, motivate movement, and support cause-effect learning. Switches are simple and intuitive, and can be mastered with low physical effort (Bailey, 1993). Behrmann, Jones, and Wilds (1989) suggested that technology can benefit young children to encourage learning, recreation, and life skills. In fact, various sensory modalities can be encouraged by technology use: Visual sensory input can be supported by flashing and blinking light toys; auditory input by tape recordings, music, sounds; and tactile input through use of vibrating toys. There has been some discussion of the motor skills (i.e., range of motion, press and release), visual perceptual skills (i.e., visual tracking, figure ground), cognitive or language skills (i.e., cause and effect, attention span that is sustained and selective, object permanence, making choices), and social skills (i.e., turn taking, following one-step directions) needed for initial switch or technology use (Behrman et al., 1989). However, these skills can be supported in young or less capable individuals to encourage participation for technology use.

Research also shows that older students with intellectual disabilities can benefit from use of microswitch technologies. In a multi-component study by Kennedy and Haring (1993), recreational stimuli were used to provide a contingency for choice. Participants used microswitches to request a change related to recreation, and the use of this technology increased the level of alertness and response to interactions by children and adolescents with intellectual disabilities in school settings.

Computer or video games provide age-appropriate, socially acceptable opportunities to both participate in preferred leisure and recreation activities and learn a number of cognitive and eye-hand coordination skills. Sedlak, Doyle, and Schloss (1982) investigated the ability of three adolescents with severe intellectual disability to learn to play a popular video game and generalize this skill to a community setting. Two of the three students were able to accomplish these objectives with a minimum of instruction and follow-up. Obviously, the nature of computer and video games has changed dramatically since this study was conducted, and there is a need for more current information about this use of technology by students with intellectual disabilities.

In another study, leisure skills, including playing cards,

selecting a television program, playing a sports videotape, and playing a computer game, were taught to four secondary students with intellectual and motor disabilities (Collins, Hall & Branson, 1997). During generalization these students were able to perform the tasks with little prompting as monitored by peers without disabilities. Increased interaction with non-disabled peers was also supported through the students’ mutual interest in the technology applications.

The World Wide Web has become a source of recreation and leisure for many people. Barriers for students with intellectual disability to use the Web include limited opportunities to use computers, lack of appropriate and cognitively accessible Internet-access software, and the complexity of computer operating systems and amount of reading required. Davies, Stock, and Wehmeyer (2001) examined a prototype Web browser, Web Trek (AbleLink Technologies), which was designed to provide access to the Internet for individuals with cognitive disabilities. The performance of 12 adolescents and young adults with intellectual disabilities was compared on two browsers – the Web Trek and Microsoft’s Internet Explorer. Measuring independence, accuracy, and task completion, participants showed significantly more success using the Web Trek browser. The Web Trek was able to reduce screen clutter to minimize confusing symbols, could be personalized to support user’s preferences, used pictures and audio prompts rather than text-based directions, and supported error minimization to support universal design for access.

Recreational pursuits such as exercise and physical fitness have also been supported with the use of technology. A study by Stanish, McCubbin, Draheim, and Mars (2001) measured the effects of leader support to facilitate engagement in moderate to vigorous physical activity related to aerobic dance with 17 adults with intellectual disabilities. The program was video-based and lasted 10 weeks. Participants were divided into two groups, one that had an exercise leader. Through the video-based exercise activities, people with mental retardation were able to engage in recreational activities that also would lead to improved health. Douglas, Douglas and Hett (1989) used technology to provide reinforcement for a 14-year-old student with moderate levels of intellectual disabilities to ride a stationary bike so that a minimum amount of teacher supervision was required for exercise to occur. Of the three conditions (i.e., television, flashing lights, or vibrator sound), the most effective reinforcing consequence for the student’s exercise behavior was vibrator sound. Another instance of exercise management was a study completed by Ellis, Cress and Spellman (1992) that used a digital kitchen timer and an adapted lap counter to facilitate self-management of exercise for five students with intellectual disabilities.

Wehmeyer17

Journal of Special Education Technology

CONCLUSION

There is only limited information about the use of technology by students with intellectual disabilities, and while there is a need for more such efforts, there is sufficient evidence that students with intellectual disabilities can benefit from technology across multiple domains. The extant literature base has a bit of a “let’s see if they can use it” feel with regard to the application of technology solutions for students with intellectual disabilities. In most cases, there is little or no evidence that the technology evaluated was designed to take into account issues of cognitive accessibility. There needs to be more research examining the impact of universal design features on technology use by students with intellectual disabilities, not so much to evaluate whether or not students can use the technology, but instead to investigate what design features can, in fact, ensure such use and benefit. Considering the characteristics of learners with intellectual disabilities, such as those discussed in this article, is important both for research and for technology design. In the meantime, however, teachers should use information about student characteristics and universal design features to evaluate and select technology that will maximally benefit students with intellectual disabilities.

REFERENCES

Abrahamson, A.A., Romski, M.A. & Sevick, R.A. (1989). Concomitants of success in acquiring an augmentative communication system: Changes in attention, communication, and sociability. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 93, 475-496.

Anderson, M.D., Sherman, J.A., Sheldon, J.B. & McAdam, D. (1997). Picture activity schedule and engagement of adults with mental retardation in a group home. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 18, 231-250.

Bailey, D.M. (1993). Technology for adults with multiple impairments: A trilogy of case reports. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 48, 341-345.

Behrmann, M.M., Jones, J.K. & Wilds, M.L. (1989). Technology interventions for very young children with disabilities.

Infants and Young Children, 1, 66-77.

Barkvik, S. & Martesson, P. (1998). Development and Adaptations in Industrial Work for People with Intellectual Disabilities; TIDE Conference, Helsinki, July 1998.

Blamires, M. (1999). Enabling technology for inclusion.

Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Blischak, D.M. (1999). Increases in natural speech production following experience with synthetic speech. Journal of Special Education Technology, 14, 44-53.

Blischak, D. M. & Lloyd, L.L.(1996). Multimodal augmentative and alternative communication: Case study. Augmentative and Alternative Communication, 12, 37-46.

Briggs, A., Alberto, P., Berlin, K., McKinley, C., Sharpton, W. & Ritts, C. (1990). Generalized use of a self-operated audio

prompt system. Education and Training in Mental Retardation, 25, 381-389.

Briggs, A., Alberto, P., Berlin, K., McKinley, C., Sharpton, W. & Ritts, C. (1990). Generalized use of a self-operated audio prompt system. Education and Training in Mental Retardation, 25, 381-389.

Browning, P., & White, W.A. (1986). Teaching life enhancement skills with interactive video-based curricula. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 21, 236-244.

Cain, E. J. (1984). The challenge of technology: Educating the exceptional child for the world of tomorrow. Teaching Exceptional Children, 16, 239-241.

Carroll, J.B. (1993). Human cognitive abilities: A survey of factor-analytic studies. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Center for Universal Design, The (1997). The principles of universal design. Accessed online at http://home. earthlink.net/~jlminc/tools_principles.html on July 31, 2003.

Collins, B.C., Hall, M. & Branson, T.A. (1997). Teaching leisure skills to adolescents with moderate disabilities. Exceptional Children, 63, 499-512.

Cuvo, A. J., & Klatt, K. P. (1992). Effects of community-based, videotape, and flash card instruction of community-referenced sight words on students with mental retardation.

Journal of Applied behavior Analysis, 25, 499-512. Danquah, S.A., Mate-Kole, C.C. & Zehr, R.T. (1996). The effect

of Danquah communication system (DanCS) boards on maladaptive behaviors among individuals with severe intellectual disabilities with severe intellectual impairment and non-verbal communication skills. International Journal of Rehabilitation Research, 19, 143-156.

Davies, D.K., Stock, S.E. & Wehmeyer, M.L. (2001). Enhancing independent internet access for individuals with mental retardation through use of specialized web browser: A pilot study. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 36, 107-113.

Davies, D. K., Stock, S. E. & Wehmeyer, M. L. (2002a). Enhancing independent task performance for individuals with mental retardation through use of a handheld self-directed visual and audio prompting system. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 37, 209-218.

Davies, D. K., Stock, S. E. & Wehmeyer, M.L. (2002b). Enhancing independent time-management skills of individuals with mental retardation using a palmtop personal computer.

Mental Retardation, 40, 358-365.

Derer, K., Polsgrove, L., & Rieth, H. (1996). A survey of assistive technology applications in schools and recommendations for practice. Journal of Special Education Technology, 13, 62 - 80.

Dicarlo, C.F. & Banajee, M. (2000). Using voice output devices to increase initiations of young children with disabilities.

Journal of Early Intervention, 23, 191-199.

18Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

Douglas, J. Douglas, A. & Hett, G. (1989). Exercise programs for special needs students: Automated contributions from the operant laboratory. British Columbia Journal of Special Education, 13, 119-125.

Dyches, T.T.(1998). Effects of switch training on the communication of children with autism and severe disabilities. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities, 13, 151-162.

Ellis, D. N., Cress, P.J. & Spellman, C.R. (1992). Using timers and lap counters to promote self-management of exercise in adolescents with mental retardation. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 27,

51-59.

Farmer, M. E., Klein, R., & Bryson, S. E. (1992). Computer-assisted reading: Effects of whole-word feedback on fluency and comprehension in readers with severe disabilities.

Remedial and Special Education, 13, 50-60.

Felce, D., & Emerson, E. (2001). Living with support in a home in the community: Predictors of behavioral development and household and community activity. Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Reviews, 7, 75 – 83.

Gaylord-Ross, R. (1987). Vocational integration for persons with mental handicaps: A cross-cultural perspective. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 8, 531-548.

Gee, K., Graham, N., Goetz, L., Oshima, G. & Yoshioka, K.(1991). Teaching students to request the continuation of routine activities by using time delay and decreasing physical assistance in the context of chain interruption. Journal of the Association of Persons with Severe Handicaps, 16, 154-167.

Hammel, J. (2000). Assistive technology and environmental intervention (AT-EI) impact on the activity and life roles of aging adults with developmental disabilities: Findings and implications for practice. Physical and Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics, 18, 37 – 58.

Hammel, J., Lai, J.S., & Heller, T. (2002). The impact of assistive technology and environmental interventions on function and living situation status with people who are ageing with developmental disabilities. Disability and Rehabilitation, 24, 93-105.

Haring, T. G., Breen, C. G., Weiner, J., Kennedy, C. H., & Bednersh, F. (1995). Using videotape modeling to facilitate generalized purchasing skills. Journal of Behavioral Education, 5, 29-53.

Hetzroni, O., Rubin, C. & Konkol, O. (2002). The use of assistive technology for symbol identification by children with Rett syndrome. Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability, 27, 57-71.

Higgins, K., & Boone, R., (1990). Hypertext computer study guides and the social studies achievement of students with learning disabilities, remedial students, and regular education students. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 529-540.

Hofmeister, A. (1984). Special education in the information age.

Peabody Journal of Education, 62(1), 5-22.

Hooper, E. H. & Hasselbring, T.S. (1985). Electronic augmentative communication aids for the nonreading student: Selection criteria. Journal of Special Education Technology, 7, 39-49.

Horn, E.M. & Warren, S.F. (1987). Facilitating the Acquisition of Sensorimotor Behavior with a Microcomputer-Mediated Teaching System: An Experimental Analysis. JASH, 12(3), 205-215.

Horton, S., Lovitt, T., & Slocum, T. (1988). Teaching geography to high school students with academic deficits: Effects of computerized map tutorial. Learning Disabilities Quarterly, 22, 102-107.

Jaspers, M., W., M., & Van Lieshout, E., C., D., M. (1994). The evaluation of two computerized instruction programs for arithmetic word-problem solving by educable mentally retarded children. Learning and Instruction, 4, 193-215.

Johnson, R.R. & Miltenberger, R.G. (1996). The direct and generalized effects of self-instruction and picture prompts on vocational task performance. Behavioral Interventions, 11, 19-34.

Kennedy, C. H. & Haring, T.G. (1993). Teaching choice making during social interactions to students with profound multiple disabilities. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 26, 63-76.

Kinney, P. G., Stevens, K. B., & Schuster, J. W. (1988). The effects of CAI and time delay: A systematic program for teaching spelling. Journal of Special Education Technology, 9, 61-72.

Lancioni, G.E. (1994). Procedures for promoting independent activity in people with severe and profound learning disability: A brief review. Mental Handicap Research, 7, 237-256.

Lancioni, G. E., Dijkstra, A. W., O'Reilly, M. F., Groeneweg, J., & Van den Hof, E. (2000). Frequent versus nonfrequent verbal prompts delivered unobtrusively: Their impact on the task performance of adults with intellectual disability. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 35(4), 428-433.

Lancioni, G.E., O’Reilly, M.F., & Campodonico, F. (2002). Promoting Fluency of performance of self-help tasks with a person with multiple disabilities. Behavioral Interventions, 17, 15-20.

Lancioni, G. E., O'Reilly, M. F., Campodonico, F., & Mantini, M. (2001). Promoting performance fluency in a person with profound intellectual disability and blindness. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 29(3), 373-377.

Lancioni, G.E., Oliva, D. & Gnocchini, F. (1996). A Visual Orientation System for Promoting Indoor Travel in Persons with Profound Developmental Disabilities and Visual Impairment. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 86, 619-626.

Lancioni, G.E., O’Reilly, M.F., Oliva, D., & Coppa, M.M. (2001a). Using multiple microswitches to promote different responses in children with multiple disabilities. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 22, 309 – 318.

Lancioni, G. E., Van den Hof, E., Furniss, F., O'Reilly, M. F., & Cunha, B. (1999). Evaluation of a computer-aided system

Wehmeyer19

Journal of Special Education Technology

providing pictorial task instructions and prompts to people with severe intellectual disability. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 43(1), 61-66.

Langone, J., Shade, J., Clees, T. J., & Day, T., (1999). Effects of multimedia instruction on teaching functional discrimination skills to students with moderate/severe intellectual disabilities. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education, 46, 493-513.

LeGrice, B. & Blampied, N.M. (1994). Training pupils with intellectual disability to operate educational technology using video prompting. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 4, 321-330.

Leung, J. (1994). Teaching simple addition to children with mental retardation using a microcomputer. Journal of Behavioral Education, 4, 355-367.

Lieber, J. and Semmel, M.I. (1985). Effectiveness of computer application to instruction with mildly handicapped learners: A review. Remedial and Special Education, 6, 5-12.

Lin, A., Podell, D. M., & Rein, N. (1991). The effects of CAI on word recognition in mildly mentally handicapped and nonhandicapped learners. Journal of Special Education Technology, 11(1), 16-25.

Lin, A., Podell, D. M., & Tournaki-Rein, N. (1994). CAI and the development of automaticity in mathematics skills in students with and without mild mental handicaps.

Computers in the Schools, 11, 43-58.

Mann, W. C. & Svorai, S. B. (1994). Compete: A Model for vocational evaluation, training, employment, and community for integration for persons with cognitive impairments. The American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 48, 446-451.

Margalit, M. & Roth, Y.B. (1989). Strategic keyboard training and spelling improvement among children with learning disabilities and mental retardation. Educational Psychology, 9, 321-329.

May, D.C. (1983). The Use of an Electronic Switch to Increase Independent head Control in a Severely Handicapped Student. Journal of Special Education Technology, 6, 14-19.

Mechling, L. C., Gast, D., L., & Langone, J. (2002). Computer-based video instruction to teach persons with moderate intellectual disabilities to read grocery aisle signs and locate items. The Journal of Special Education, 35, 224-240.

Meyers, L.F. (1994). Access and meaning: The keys to effective computer use by children with language disabilities. Journal of Special Education Technology, 257-275.

Mitchell, R. J., Schuster, J. W., Collins, B. C. & Gassaway, L. J. (2000). Teaching vocational skills with a faded auditory prompting system. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 35, 415-427.

Morgan, R., L., & Salzberg, C. L., (1992). Effects of video-assisted training on employment-related social skills of adults with severe mental retardation. Journal of Applied Behvaior Analysis, 25, 365-383.

Mustonen, T., Locke, P., Reichle, J., Solbrack, M. & Londgren, A.(1991). An overview of augmentative and alternative communication systems. In J. Reichle, J. York & J. Sigafoos (Eds.) . Implementing augmentative and alternative communication: Strategies for learners with severe disabilities (pp. 1-37). Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes.

National Center on Educational Statistics (2001). Computer and Internet Use by Children and Adolescents in 2001. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.

National Council on Disability (1996). Access to the Information Superhighway and Emerging Information Technologies by People with Disabilities. (ONLINE: Accessed April 24, 2004 from http://www.ncd.gov/newsroom/publications/super hwy.html)

Podell, D. M., Tournaki-Rein, N., & Lin, A. (1992). Automatization of mathematics skills via computer-assisted instruction among students with mild mental handicaps.

Education and Training in Mental Retardation, 27, 200-206. Riley, K., Bodine, C, Hills, J., Gane, L. Sanstrum, J., & Hagerman, R. (2001). The tickle box assistive technology device piloted on a young woman with Fragile X syndrome.

Mental Health Aspects of Developmental Disabilities, 4, 138-142.

Romski, M.A. & Sevick, R. (1988). Augmentative and alternative communication systems: Considerations for individuals with severe intellectual disabilities. Augmentative and Alternative Communication, 4, 83-93.

Romski, M. A. & Sevcik, R. (1996). Breaking the speech barrier: Language development through augmented means.

Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes.

Schepis, M.M., Reid, D.H. & Behrman, M.M.& Sutton, (1998). Increasing communicative interactions of young children with autism using a voice output communication aid and naturalistic teaching. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 31, 561-578.

Sedlak, R.A., Doyle, M. & Schloss, P. (1982). Video games: A training and generalization demonstration with severely retarded adolescents. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 17, 332-336.

Sigafoos, J. & Iacono, T.(1993). Selecting augmentative communication devices for persons with severe disabilities: Some factors for educational teams to consider. Australia and New Zealand Journal of Developmental Disabilities, 18,

133-146.

Stanish, H.I., McCubbin, J.A., Draheim, C.C.,& Van der Mars, H. (2001). Participation of adults with mental retardation in a video- and leader- directed aerobic dance program. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 18, 142-155.

Stevens, K.B., Blackhurst, A.E., Slaton, D.B.(1991). Teaching memorized spelling with a microcomputer: Time delay and computer-assisted instruction. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 24, 153-160.

Storey, K. & O’Neil, P. (1996). The effect of communication skills instruction on the integration of workers with severe

20Overview of Technology Use

Journal of Special Education Technology

disabilitiesinsupportedemploymentsettings.

Communication Instruction, 123-141.

Taber, T. A., Alberto, P. A. & Fredrick, L. D. (1998). Use of self-operated auditory prompts by workers with moderate mental retardation to transition independently through vocational tasks. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 19, 327-345.

Telecommunications Access Committee (1999). Telecommunications Act accessibility guidelines. Retrieved May 24, 2004 from http://www.access-board.gov/telecomm/ about%20telecomm.htm.

Wacker, D.P., Wiggins, B., Fowler, M. & Berg, W.K. (1988). Training students with profound or multiple handicaps to make requests via microswitches. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21, 331-343.

Wehmeyer, M. L. (1999). Assistive technology and students with mental retardation: Utilization and barriers. Journal of Special Education Technology, 14, 50 - 60.

Wehmeyer, M.L., Smith, S., & Davies, D.K. (in press). Technology use and students with intellectual disability: Universal design for all students. In D. Edyburn (Ed.),

Handbook of Technology and Special Education.

Wehmeyer, M.L., Smith, S.J., Palmer, S.B., Davies, D.K., & Stock, S. (2004). Technology use and people with mental retardation. In L.M. Glidden (Ed.), International Review of Research in Mental Retardation (pp. 291-337). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.

Wissick, C., A., Lloyd, J. L., & Kinzie, M. (1992). The effects of community training using a videodisc-based simulation.

Journal of Special Education Technology, 9, 207-222. Woodward, J., & Rieth, H. (1997). A historical review of

technology research in special education. Review of Educational Research, 67(4), 503-536.

Michael Wehmeyer is Associate Professor in the Department of Special Education at the University of Kansas. Sean Smith is Assistant Professor in the Department of Special Education at University of Kansas. Susan Palmer is Assistant Research Professor in the Beach Center on Disability at the University of Kansas. Daniel Davies is president of AbleLink Technologies. Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Michael Wehmeyer, Beach Center on Disability, Room 3136, 1200 Sunnyside Ave., Lawrence, KS, 66045-7534. Email to: [email protected].

DMU Timestamp: January 21, 2020 02:52





Image
0 comments, 0 areas
add area
add comment
change display
Video
add comment

Quickstart: Commenting and Sharing

How to Comment
  • Click icons on the left to see existing comments.
  • Desktop/Laptop: double-click any text, highlight a section of an image, or add a comment while a video is playing to start a new conversation.
    Tablet/Phone: single click then click on the "Start One" link (look right or below).
  • Click "Reply" on a comment to join the conversation.
How to Share Documents
  1. "Upload" a new document.
  2. "Invite" others to it.

Logging in, please wait... Blue_on_grey_spinner