As David Fromkin put it in his widely praised history of World War I and its aftermath, “A Peace to End All Peace”: “Rape and beating were commonplace. Those who were not killed at once were driven through mountains and deserts without food, drink or shelter. Hundreds of thousands of Armenians eventually succumbed or were killed .”
The man who invented the word “genocide”— Raphael Lemkin, a lawyer of Polish-Jewish origin — was moved to investigate the attempt to eliminate an entire people by accounts of the massacres of Armenians. He did not, however, coin the word until 1943, applying it to Nazi Germany and the Jews in a book published a year later, “Axis Rule in Occupied Europe.”
But to Turks, what happened in 1915 was, at most, just one more messy piece of a very messy war that spelled the end of a once-powerful empire. They reject the conclusions of historians and the term genocide, saying there was no premeditation in the deaths, no systematic attempt to destroy a people. Indeed, in Turkey today it remains a crime — “insulting Turkishness” — to even raise the issue of what happened to the Armenians.
In the United States, a powerful Armenian community centered in Los Angeles has been pressing for years for Congress to condemn the Armenian genocide. Turkey, which cut military ties to France over a similar action, has reacted with angry threats. A bill to that effect nearly passed in the fall of 2007, gaining a majority of co-sponsors and passing a committee vote. But the Bush administration, noting that Turkey is a critical ally — more than 70 per cent of the military air supplies for Iraq go through the Incirlik airbase there — pressed for the bill to be withdrawn, and it was.
The roots of the genocide lie in the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.
The empire’s ruler was also the caliph, or leader of the Islamic community. Minority religious communities, like the Christian Armenians, were allowed to maintain their religious, social and legal structures, but were often subject to extra taxes or other measures.
Concentrated largely in eastern Anatolia, many of them merchants and industrialists, Armenians, historians say, appeared markedly better off in many ways than their Turkish neighbors, largely small peasants or ill-paid government functionaries and soldiers.
At the turn of the 20th Century, the once far-flung Ottoman empire was crumbling at the edges, beset by revolts among Christian subjects to the north — vast swaths of territory were lost in the Balkan Wars of 1912-13 — and the subject of coffee house grumbling among Arab nationalist intellectuals in Damascus and elsewhere.
The Young Turk movement of ambitious, discontented junior army officers seized power in 1908, determined to modernize, strengthen and “Turkify” the empire. They were led by what became an all-powerful triumvirate sometimes referred to as the Three Pashas.
In March of 1914, the Young Turks entered World War I on the side of Germany. They attacked to the east, hoping to capture the city of Baku in what would be a disastrous campaign against Russian forces in the Caucuses. They were soundly defeated at the battle of Sarikemish.
Armenians in the area were blamed for siding with the Russians and the Young Turks began a campaign to portray the Armenians as a kind of fifth column, a threat to the state. Indeed, there were Armenian nationalists who acted as guerrillas and cooperated with the Russians. They briefly seized the city of Van in the spring of 1915.
Armenians mark the date April 24, 1915, when several hundred Armenian intellectuals were rounded up, arrested and later executed as the start of the Armenian genocide and it is generally said to have extended to 1917. However, there were also massacres of Armenians in 1894, 1895, 1896, 1909, and a reprise between 1920 and 1923.
The University of Minnesota’s Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies has compiled figures by province and district that show there were 2,133,190 Armenians in the empire in 1914 and only about 387,800 by 1922.
Writing at the time of the early series of massacres, The New York Times suggested there was already a “policy of extermination directed against the Christians of Asia Minor.”
The Young Turks, who called themselves the Committee of Unity and Progress, launched a set of measures against the Armenians, including a law authorizing the military and government to deport anyone they “sensed” was a security threat.
A later law allowed the confiscation of abandoned Armenian property. Armenians were ordered to turn in any weapons that they owned to the authorities. Those in the army were disarmed and transferred into labor battalions where they were either killed or worked to death.
There were executions into mass graves, and death marches of men, women and children across the Syrian desert to concentration camps with many dying along the way of exhaustion, exposure and starvation.
Much of this was quite well documented at the time by Western diplomats, missionaries and others, creating widespread wartime outrage against the Turks in the West. Although its ally, Germany, was silent at the time, in later years documents have surfaced from ranking German diplomats and military officers expressing horror at what was going on.
Some historians, however, while acknowledging the widespread deaths, say what happened does not technically fit the definition of genocide largely because they do not feel there is evidence that it was well-planned in advance.
The New York Times covered the issue extensively — 145 articles in 1915 alone by one count — with headlines like “Appeal to Turkey to Stop Massacres.” The Times described the actions against the Armenians as “systematic,” “authorized, and “organized by the government.”
The American ambassador, Henry Morganthau Sr., was also outspoken. In his memoirs, the ambassador would write: “When the Turkish authorities gave the orders for these deportations, they were merely giving the death warrant to a whole race; they understood this well, and in their conversations with me, they made no particular attempt to conceal the fact.”
Following the surrender of the Ottoman Empire in 1918, the Three Pashas fled to Germany, where they were given protection. But the Armenian underground formed a group called Operation Nemesis to hunt them down. On March 15, 1921, one of the pashas was shot dead on a street in Berlin in broad daylight in front of witnesses. The gunman pled temporary insanity brought on by the mass killings and a jury took only a little over an hour to acquit him. It was the defense evidence at this trial that drew the interest of Mr. Lemkin, the coiner of “genocide.”
Logging in, please wait...
0 General Document comments
0 Sentence and Paragraph comments
0 Image and Video comments
Comments are due March 01, 2019 00:00
You've made 0 of the 5 requested
New Conversation
New Conversation
I wonder if Adolf Hitler had some inspiration from this horrible genocide, as he did a similar thing dung WW2.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
I guess we’ll never really know a true answer
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
Evan Higdon
Evan Higdon
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
Why would the Ottoman Empire kill over a million and a half Armenians.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
Peace doesn’t seem like rape and beating. Peace does not seem like killing over a million people.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
How is killing millions called the “Peace to end all Peace”?
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
Evan Higdon
Evan Higdon
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Why wouldn’t they own up to the deaths years after it happened? It doesn’t reflect them anymore and each country has made mistakes in its past
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
I understand why they would deny killing 1.5 million people. It seems odd that other countries would not help.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
Evan Higdon
Evan Higdon
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Would it be too difficult to do this? Why would the United States just pass off the Armenian genocide? They should condemn it, in my opinion.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
The nation was already pretty unstable, any ideas on why they chose to enter the war. It seems like a really risky move.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
If this hadn’t happened there may not have been a motive for committing the genocide.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
The split of the nation between Armenians and Turkish is fascinating with siding with opposite sides of the war and adding propaganda.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Although the 2 countries were at war, there is no excuse to commit genocide on a mass scale. Especially if they aren’t even part of the war effort.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
Evan Higdon
Evan Higdon
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
The motives for this genecide remind me of Hitler in a way. They were both trying to better their own nation by getting rid of an enemy, or in hitlers case, killing “Lesser races”
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Turks for Unity and Progress are against Armenians seems very hypocritical. An odd choice of word pairing and actions that can be seen done many other times as well.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
This policy seems very vauge, how was a security threat justified?
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Evan Higdon
Evan Higdon
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
Somehow the rest of the world called this “The Peace to End all Peace”.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
Although they were in a militrized zone, this seems dehumanising. One quality of humanity is that we respect the dead, yet a mass grave is a huge disrespect
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
It makes me wonder if Germany had the power to stop the genocide or if they did but just did not do anything about it.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
Even if Germany was their allies, they should have interfered. Other countries too. This is very unjust and their actions shouldn’t go unpunished especially when they’re this awful.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Even if it was, there was still a mass killing of people and as previous students have stated, genocide is a deliberate killing of a large group of people.
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
Although there’s evidence suggesting this is a genocide, the fact that this wasn’t very thought out or planned makes it strange. On a whim, they killed so many Armenians and reduced their population by such a large amount
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Does a genecide have to be expertly planned? Having a bunch of bodies on your hands should be enough to justify genicide right?
New Conversation
Hide Full Comment
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
New Conversation
General Document Comments 0
New Conversation
Hide Thread Detail
New Conversation